Best Fantasy Novels

Membres
337 membres participants
1
47,179 membres
452 critiques
½ 4.5
On Member Lists
sdobie, dhm, Aquila, Julie_in_the_Library, HAAAM, lcrider, fvenez, Sakinthra, Brandy1411, benskinner, AlejandroSalas, DorothySKT, julfeniks, Morphidae, Brightcarvings, novicebaker, ignatious1, TeriAndersonNeedham, m_island, heavy-hannu, Ted_Herman, elizaforest, HChilcat, OwenRochester, elainemberman, michaela_vy, nhlsecord, sjmaliszewski, Rtrace, jdyork74, Saxon451, LarraChersan, jfdejonge, Euryale, feeling.is.first, ThePortPorts, anyother, vemace, corporate_clone, lexxnet1972, falkman, ebnelson, pmdean, RBette1299, santhony, Demth, richard.gray, kceccato, Bookkat33, Peace2, loremistress, Rouge2507, Rbrancher2, dsp501, Taismathias, varielle, bjappleg8, AriesWang, linlef, rubyott, navelos, smexiiangelbabe, Matteocalosi, blackdove07, Sambella, StuckSouth, scorpiusx1, deerhorne, Elizabeth088, ahef1963, al.vick, raperper, Jannes, briarhills, rarm, eclecticdodo, Cecrow, Luisali, Percevan, rretzler, Beorn_se_Bacaire, devenish, scriptus, amobogio, DaynaRT, Jeffsul, GreenSpectre, Herenya, kgodey, Crypto-Willobie, ncgraham, lorax, Athabasca, Storeetllr, souloftherose, lquilter, mkjones, foggidawn, staffordcastle, Mr.Durick, ijustgetbored, Edward, StephenBarkley, timspalding, quigui, geitebukkeskjegg, brightcopy, Minionsama, LARA335, Mguod, Diana-Book-Fan, WildMaggie, b1_, Rensslaer, mre9, kiwiflowa, macha, tottman, Ravic, ErlendSkjelten, Samantha_kathy, birder4106, LShelby, fabtk, Dcarrnyus, Readatron, binarydude, peterveen, ghilbrae, mike_frank, LisaMaria_C, chgstrom, elenchus, snurp, anglemark, k.leine, trollsdotter, Vulco1, Picarina, BomboChipolata, calm, daschaich, CurrerBell, Quaisior, KimarieBee, gypsysmom, DeusXMachina, Dilara86, Jarandel, merrystar, el_len, cej1027, ManWithAnAgenda, avm1863, timetunnel, Southuhnboi, clong, jjwilson61, Moomin_Mama, cthulhuslibrarian, norabelle414, Myyst
Thumbs Down
superdeeblaine, Kattermole, morgenfee, Rohith.Ramanujam, Anjali.Negi, rocketmac360, electrice, MaskedMumbler, LamontCranston, PitcherBooks, auntSteelbreaker, mspixieears
Explications
electrice : not a single book
Crypto-Willobie: Actually Lord of the Rings IS a single book. It was written and submitted that way. The original publisher divided it into three volumes for marketing reasons. It's not a true 'trilogy' but rather a very long single novel.
Score
546.48
2
85,325 membres
1,133 critiques
½ 4.3
On Member Lists
Sammil42, jvidinha, brunomac27, Denewell, Horacioalrcn, jbartle2, canVANucks, kristilabrie, macha, BruceCoulson, PitcherBooks, Julilla, JqnOC, Julie_in_the_Library, HAAAM, Sakinthra, Brandy1411, julfeniks, Morphidae, Brightcarvings, ignatious1, TeriAndersonNeedham, OwenRochester, elainemberman, michaela_vy, nhlsecord, sjmaliszewski, Rtrace, Saxon451, LarraChersan, jfdejonge, Euryale, ThePortPorts, anyother, holbie, vemace, lexxnet1972, falkman, pmdean, santhony, Demth, kceccato, Bookkat33, Peace2, loremistress, Rbrancher2, varielle, merrystar, bjappleg8, AriesWang, linlef, rubyott, smexiiangelbabe, blackdove07, Sambella, StuckSouth, scorpiusx1, Elizabeth088, ahef1963, al.vick, raperper, Jannes, briarhills, mike_frank, eclecticdodo, rretzler, devenish, scriptus, dementomstie, amobogio, sdobie, Minionsama, fvenez, Dcarrnyus, WildMaggie, Rensslaer, mre9, kiwiflowa, quigui, DaynaRT, RBette1299, LShelby, Percevan, fabtk, Mguod, Readatron, peterveen, elenchus, rarm, Edward, Jeffsul, timspalding, k.leine, navelos, Cecrow, Aerrin99, SylviaC, Luisali, enrique_molinero, bonne1978, jdyork74, souloftherose, BomboChipolata, kara.shamy, LisaMaria_C, Matteocalosi, kerrygiven, mrmapcase, Quaisior, DeusXMachina, CurrerBell, gypsysmom, ncgraham, paradoxosalpha, foggidawn, sturlington, Dilara86, kgodey, Crypto-Willobie, ManWithAnAgenda, MikeBriggs, jules_l, Jarandel, novicebaker, el_len, avm1863, cej1027, Moomin_Mama, cthulhuslibrarian, Southuhnboi, Myyst, norabelle414, mspixieears
Thumbs Down
Rohith.Ramanujam, rocketmac360, bormgans, Friederike.Geissler, MaskedMumbler, LamontCranston
Score
380.9
4
On Member Lists
beaxt, teresalane5392, kara.shamy, Anjali.Negi, chgstrom, swr0808, holbie, tottman, dementomstie, LisaMaria_C, ABVR, prosfilaes, susiesharp, birder4106, jvidinha, jdyork74, rocketmac360, sarrahchang, stevengolson, PitcherBooks, Herenya, kgodey, foggidawn, KC9333, gilroy, LARA335, julfeniks, Morphidae, elainemberman, Denewell, LarraChersan, feeling.is.first, anyother, scorpiusx1, Elizabeth088, ahef1963, al.vick, briarhills, eclecticdodo, Samantha_kathy, dwacker, lorax, hailelib, EmScape, Minionsama, Diana-Book-Fan, TeriAndersonNeedham, OwenRochester, michaela_vy, nhlsecord, sjmaliszewski, k.leine, Rtrace, falkman, pmdean, mre9, kiwiflowa, kceccato, Bookkat33, Rbrancher2, varielle, AriesWang, smexiiangelbabe, Cecrow, rretzler, Jeffsul, GreenVelvet, staffordcastle, brightcopy, HAAAM, scriptus, Aerrin99, Soupdragon, binarydude, rarm, alvaret, arienrhod1, BomboChipolata, Dilara86, RBette1299, qhmisty119, mike_frank, KimarieBee, elizaforest, DeusXMachina, CurrerBell, ncgraham, pwaites, el_len, macha, avm1863, norabelle414, cej1027
Thumbs Down
ManWithAnAgenda, jain, acceptance, frankschaper, merrystar, b1_, Peace2, electrice, santhony, MaskedMumbler, BeniBela, LamontCranston, jjwilson61, andyl, deerhorne, Jannes, JGKC, Percevan, Ravic, devenish, Edward, sandstone78, DaynaRT, anglemark, aulsmith, ijustgetbored, _Zoe_, auntSteelbreaker, corporate_clone, mspixieears
Explications
electrice : not a single book
jjwilson61 : Not a novel
corporate_clone: not a single novel
Score
212.94
5
On Member Lists
nagasravika.bodapati, Diane.Henson, Stephan_Rogers, marilenaaa, sarahherring402, Rohith.Ramanujam, brandymt, adsddy, stevengolson, Courtibert, bonne1978, dhm, teresalane5392, swr0808, alvaret, BruceCoulson, timspalding, SylviaC, brightcopy, jvidinha, RodgerA, holbie, kristilabrie, Demth, loremistress, PitcherBooks, Valari2, foggidawn, ncgraham, HAAAM, Sakinthra, elainemberman, Anjali.Negi, Sambella, Minionsama, Morphidae, Brightcarvings, OwenRochester, nhlsecord, sjmaliszewski, Rtrace, Denewell, pmdean, santhony, kceccato, dsp501, rubyott, geitebukkeskjegg, souloftherose, dwacker, LarraChersan, kiwiflowa, AriesWang, smexiiangelbabe, devenish, Jeffsul, Diana-Book-Fan, Bookkat33, ErlendSkjelten, Aerrin99, Elizabeth088, EmScape, jdyork74, Soupdragon, Herenya, ahef1963, al.vick, rarm, gypsysmom, kerrygiven, merrystar, mike_frank, jules_l, anglemark, ManWithAnAgenda, RBette1299, hipdeep, novicebaker, el_len, Cecrow, avm1863, cej1027, Moomin_Mama, mspixieears, cthulhuslibrarian, norabelle414
Thumbs Down
Ron18, elizaforest, andomck, keristars, anyother, MaskedMumbler, LamontCranston, Percevan, CurrerBell, Quaisior, aulsmith, Edward
Explications
Ron18 : Lewis is ultimately a tortured soul who would do anything to convince himself that fantasy is reality, in order to make sense of the death and suffering he witnessed and experienced. Shoehorning his beliefs into the minds of the young isn't a harmless experiment to be taken lightly.
aulsmith : I really hated all the allegory in what started out as a decent fantasy.
Score
210.81
69
7,176 membres
349 critiques
4.1
On Member Lists
akbookworm33445, el_len, electrice, KimarieBee, jason9292, enrique_molinero, Rensslaer, jain, MikeBriggs, connie53, foggidawn, ErlendSkjelten, stevengolson, loremistress, BomboChipolata, rarm, sdobie, elizaforest, RBette1299, gypsysmom, Brightcarvings, DDreawriter, Rtrace
Thumbs Down
aulsmith, santhony, anglemark, brdmom1
Explications
electrice: read in 2013, alternate history where Napoleonic's Wars happen with sentient dragons
Score
38.57
77
3,414 membres
39 critiques
4.1
On Member Lists
adsddy, vemace, dsp501, k.leine, Saxon451, Sambella, Peace2, feeling.is.first, PitcherBooks, anyother, nhlsecord, avm1863, varielle, elizaforest, taxonet, TeriAndersonNeedham, loremistress, Brightcarvings, al.vick, OwenRochester, Cecrow, DDreawriter, ahef1963, brdmom1
Thumbs Down
Quaisior, gypsysmom, merrystar, aulsmith, santhony
Explications
Quaisior : It's science fiction.
gypsysmom : McCaffrey's books are science fiction, not fantasy.
aulsmith : Not a single novel. I think she meant it to be science fiction.
Score
35
82
92,540 membres
835 critiques
½ 4.3
On Member Lists
Kiddboyblue, m_island, mrmapcase, kerrygiven, jules_l, avm1863, rocketmac360, Euryale, varielle, jdyork74, elizaforest, swr0808, TeriAndersonNeedham, connie53, sdobie, Rtrace, blackdove07, RBette1299, Cecrow, el_len, cej1027, mspixieears
Thumbs Down
ManWithAnAgenda, benskinner, megschristina, gilroy
Explications
gilroy : The end of the series wasn't great. I just wouldn't put HP 5, 6, or 7 here.
Score
33
99
3,016 membres
44 critiques
3.9
On Member Lists
aulsmith, SylviaC, LisaMaria_C, Saxon451, avm1863, Peace2, Bookkat33, TeriAndersonNeedham, Cecrow, Rtrace, DDreawriter, cej1027, brdmom1, mspixieears
Thumbs Down
ncgraham
Explications
aulsmith: The original 1939 edition. Changed my life.
Score
26.64