Photo de l'auteur
12 oeuvres 34 utilisateurs 2 critiques

Séries

Œuvres de David Wake

Étiqueté

Partage des connaissances

Il n’existe pas encore de données Common Knowledge pour cet auteur. Vous pouvez aider.

Membres

Critiques

Earnestine, Georgina and Charlotte are the three Deering-Dolittle sisters, banished to a Swiss boarding school because of Charlotte's reprehensible contact with the cadets from the boys' school near their last boarding school.

Earnestine is the eldest, and determined to look after the other two, and keep them on the straight and narrow path of proper young Victorian ladies (no exploring!).

Georgina isn't keen on exploring, and wants to get married and do embroidery. I liked Georgina the best (it was really Georgina who made me want to read Book 1 after reading Book 3); when push comes to shove, Georgina is capable of working out just where she ought to shove. And she's the one who works out how to drive the steam engine. Go Georgina!

Charlotte is the youngest, and her interest in the young cadets at the boys' school turns out to be rather more useful than might be assumed, and not what the cadets themselves might have hoped.

The author is very careful to give each sister a viewpoint section in strict rotation, starting with Earnestine, which is proper because she's the eldest. This works well, because - as intended - it ensures that all three sisters are joint heroines, rather than one of them taking the lead.

The overall feel is steampunk-light, but this is possibly rather more to do with the writing style than the content, since the very first thing that happens is the murder of an entire boarding school of young ladies. Various other dangers happen (obviously, or it would be a short, boring book) - again, cementing Georgina as my favourite Deering-Dolittle. She might not be as 'flashy' as her sisters, but Georgina's determination to do the right thing (and, of all the things the sisters have to do, I think Georgina has the worst task of all - read the book to find out what it is) is all the more powerful because she's the quiet one who doesn't want adventures.

There are zombies, airships, a steam train, explosions, dastardly villains, etc, etc. There is, however, a distressing lack of embroidery. A pity. Georgina's not the only one who likes embroidery.

All in all, an excellent entertaining read.
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
T_K_Elliott | Mar 12, 2017 |
Earnestine, Georgina and Charlotte are back for their third definitely-not-an-adventure (although each book stands alone, so you don’t necessarily have to read them in order if you don’t want to).

This time, it’s strange lights in the sky, little grey men in the kitchen, and the devil in the village. Also, spies. And kidnapping. And pirates. And worse things, like spelling and grammar. Once more, the British Empire (or the whole of civilisation, even) is at risk, and only the Derring-Do Club can save the day, the Empire, and possibly all of civilisation.

My favourite sister is still Georgina; although she’s the quietest one, and the only sister who really doesn’t like adventures (no matter what Earnestine says), I think she is in some ways the strongest of the three. No matter what life (or the author) does to her, or expects of her, Georgina does what’s right. Plus, she’s the scientist of the trio: very cool.

I’ve said it before, and will doubtless say it again: these books are fun romps. Well-written, fast-paced, and dangerously addictive - but with some extra thinking in there, too, should you choose to read it that way.

Once more, David Wake has demonstrated his ability to tell a story that is even more satisfying than you think it will be going in (even with the high expectations I now have of him!) and I’m looking forward to the next book - a little snippet of which is included at the end of the kindle edition of this one.
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
T_K_Elliott | Mar 12, 2017 |

Statistiques

Œuvres
12
Membres
34
Popularité
#413,653
Évaluation
½ 4.7
Critiques
2
ISBN
12