7P

What was your final rating for the book? Why?

I was torn between 4.5 and 5, but given my complaints at the end of several sections about the story dragging slightly and being marked down because of this, I had to go the same way in all consciousness in the end - final rating, 4.5. (Sorry, Rollins. But you were so-o close...)

I stayed with my 4. I got so weary of reading the explanations. Loved seeing old Cassander turned into a a part of the glass menagerie.

>3 Carol420: Andrew posed a question about this scene (7L) which gets lost because the q's go into a second page - you only get to this missing question by touching "Last Message" at the top of the list, here's a link http://www.librarything.com/topic/271172

>4 Sergeirocks: They still haven't solved that issue.

I'll end with a 4 too since we had so many pages to read and it could have been shortened.

>4 Sergeirocks: I pick up the questions under the Talk category so I didn't have a problem finding 7L.

I decided to go to 4. Overall an enjoyable read but I never rushed back to pick it up again after answering the questions.

My final rating due to the ending was 4.5. Interestingly I just checked back, I read this over 6 1/2 years ago and gave it exactly the same rating!

I'm going to end at 3.75.