Victoria Abbott RiccardiCritiques

I have a fascination with Japanese culture and I am also interested in food so I thought I would love this book. Unfortuntely, after a solid opening chapter it just turned in to a hum-drum book for me. It was OK but I wasn't excited to come back to reading it when I took a break and overall found it all rather dull.

I love Japanese cuisine but tea kaiseki has remained a mystery even as I indulged in a tourist version in Kyoto. Riccardi walks us through that wonderful world, full of subtleties, delicacies and new tastes. It made me appreciate Japanese culture even more, and although I'm not a big cook, I'm tempted to try one of the many recipes included in the book to recapture some of the unique flavours which are not easily available in Canada - the trick will be finding the ingredients! The book does contain a thoughtful glossary to help the reader navigate all the intricacies of tastes and manners.
A fascinating and accessible read.

Perfectly nice book—nothing wrong with a three star rating—but not especially spectacular. If you're interested in the subject (food in Kyoto, in the 1980s, with an emphasis of tea kaiseki) you will enjoy this greatly. But (unlike M.F.K. Fisher's work, say) it doesn't rise above the level of interesting/diverting to become some kind of culinary classic.

(Note: 5 stars = amazing, wonderful, 4 = very good book, 3 = decent read, 2 = disappointing, 1 = awful, just awful. I'm fairly good at picking for myself so end up with a lot of 4s). I feel a lot of readers automatically render any book they enjoy 5, but I grade on a curve!

Incredible, detailed, picturesque descriptions of food in Kyoto. But probably a little too detailed in places, and certainly would be tiresome for non-foodies. Good recipes though! And helpful glossary.

Victoria Abbott had always been in love with Japan, perhaps because her grandparents often traveled there and brought back exotic gifts. So when she had the chance to live in Kyoto and learn the art of tea kaiseki, she jumped at it. Tea kaiseki is a meal consisting of several courses that is served before the better-known tea ceremony. It is practically an art form, with each course tied in somehow to the seasons or to the climactic dish, and replete with symbolic meanings. While there, she attended the Mushanokji school to learn this type of cooking, taught English, and learned much about Japanese culture and philosophy that greatly impacted her life. At the end of several chapters, the author includes a few recipes (27 in total) of the food discussed in that chapter.

I enjoyed the idea of this travelogue/cookbook and the window it gives into a lesser-known aspect of Japanese culture. Niggling details lessened my enjoyment, however, particularly the general choppiness of the narrative from sentence fragments to short chapters that felt tacked on to lengthen the book. On one occasion, the author oversimplified, identifying manga only as the comics that businessmen would read to fulfill their fantasies of school girls, rather than the broader range of comics for varying age groups that it truly is. This made me wonder if there were any other areas where she described something in broad strokes that might in actuality be a little different from her interpretation. She also tended towards repetitiveness, such as continually pointing out the difference between tea kaiseki and restaurant kaiseki, rather than mentioning it once, and then depending on her wonderful descriptions of each to reinforce her point. Riccardi was at her best when she describes the food she encounters - from the taste to the presentation to the symbolic meaning of ingredients - which made me want to try some of the recipes included.

Wonderful narative with good recipes

As a rare foreign student of traditional Japanese cooking, Riccardi has an experience in Japan unique from other travelers'. Sadly, she shares her story in overwrought metaphors and nearly unreadable meditations on tofu. I loved her perspective on living abroad -- that "when you leave a meal, or a moment, or a place not compltely satisfied, you cherish it that much more because it left you wanting" -- but one good passage does not a good book make.

I love good food writing, and i like writing about Japanese culture, so a book about Japanese food culture has a good chance in my library:) Fortunately for me, Abbott Riccardi is a good writer and has written an entertaining and informative book.

The author travelled to Japan, partly based on memories of gifts brought back from Kyoto by her grandparents, and partly based on a wanting to learn 'kaiseki' which is the cuisine that accompanies the tea ceremony. The author does a good job of explaining the food and the rituals, as well as exploring Japanese culture in a subtle way - while she is open in her opinions, she lets her observations of the food and its preparation tell us the most about her time in Japan.
This book does have some recipes, though you will probably need an Asian/Japanese food speciality shop nearby to cook any of them. But it is the food writing that makes this book. If you are a fan of writers such as MFK Fisher, you are probably going to like this book!

The author journeyed to Kyoto to study, not just any Japanese cookery, but the haute cuisine known as kaiseki. This, in turn, comes in two flavours. One type of kaiseki is served in restaurants, while another is exclusive to Chado, the tea ceremony. Abbott Riccardi was trained in both. It's an absorbing story, although I'm a little puzzled at the author's apparent lack of curiosity in Chado; only the food aspect of tea ceremony seems to interest her.½