Penelope A. LewisCritiques

Interesting subject matter nicely researched but the overall presentation left a lot to be desired!

The chapters could have been better organised and edited.

I may revisit this title at some point or simply look up if better options are available on this fascinating area and well presented research.½

This is a pretty good book brining together research and current day insights of the sleeping process. Dream are referred to, but this book is not for that kind of analysis. Dreams do process daytime events, particularly ones with a significant emotional impact,, but the question is open as to how ell this is understood.

It should be emphasized that this book is written for the interested layperson—so even though there is significant emphasis on neural processes and intimidating-sounding stuff like "neurotransmitters" and "acetylcholine" and "action potentials", it gets explained within the first few chapters. This means that it's potentially a little boring to people who are more familiar with the brain, but also means it's much more accessible to those who aren't!

Also of note is that this isn't a book on how to improve your sleep, but I think that much should be obvious from the title—it's about the functionality of sleep and what aspects of consciousness it contributes to. So if you're a layperson suffering from insomnia and want to improve your sleep habits, you should NOT pick up this book. But if you're the average person who wants to know more about what goes on when you're sleeping, by all means, this is the kind of book you want!

This book is divided roughly into three parts: About the brain, the brain and sleeping/dreaming, and ways to improve your sleep (either overall or to get your sleep to work for you).

The "about the brain" section is extremely basic, but it's also written clearly for the kind of information that the author is trying to get across. I admired the author on this point, since she knew exactly what the uninitiated reader needed to know to understand the rest of the book, and describes only that and nothing else. (This may be disappointing to those who wanted to know a little more about the brain, however.)

The brain and sleep/dreaming section is likely the reason why the book was bought in the first place. Like the author states several times, sleep (and dreaming!) is a rather mysterious beast that we don't know a whole lot about yet, but it seems to be exceedingly important in the functioning of memory and learning. Dreams also have some effect. The author goes into detail about a few particular studies, likely chosen to have a wow factor, since detailing a lot of research would have an unintended soporific effect. Another bonus is that there are a few highly contentious cases that the author details the arguments (and research) for and against a particular research question. It's easy to tell the side that she takes, since she goes into much more detail at that point, but I appreciate that she makes an effort to disclose both sides.

The "improving your sleep" section spans two chapters, the first on how to get your sleep to work for you, and the second on how to improve your sleep in general. I don't think there's anything particularly special in these two chapters; the latter is information that you can get from a rousing Google search, but the former is more interesting.

In the end, this book is tightly written and doesn't have a lot of extraneous material—in fact, it left me a little dissatisfied because I wanted to know more. I would have liked a little more connection between the neurological and psychological findings regarding sleep, since this book focuses mainly on the brain and less on the mind (and I know there are interesting psychological theories of sleep!); however, that may have detracted from the to-the-point quality of the book that I did enjoy. The figures and diagrams weren't the most helpful or clear (or practical, from an academic standpoint), so I eventually just stopped looking at them altogether. The author writes clearly enough that I never felt like I needed a visual explanation.

I was looking forward to reading this book but found it to be a frustrating and ultimately disappointing read. I just couldn’t figure out author Stephanie Lewis’ purpose in writing it. Too technical for a lay audience and not technical enough for a scholarly work, it reads like an introductory textbook on cognitive science---complete with chapter summaries---for students. And while there are a few interesting facts to be found, you have to slog through an awful lot of jargon-laden prose; needless charts, graphs and diagrams; and more detail than you would ever want or need to know about laboratory experiments and brain topography to get there.½

I enjoyed the mix of science and practicality and despite having done lots of reading on sleep and brain development, did learn some new tidbits. The information on memory formation was fairly new to me. Some sections would be hard going for anyone who doesn't enjoy more technical reading.

I received a copy of this book courtesy of the publishers via the LibraryThing Early Reviewers programme in exchange for an honest review.

The Secret World of Sleep is a very useful and informative book. It provides non-science readers and students an update on what’s been researched recently about everything sleep-related and the brain’s role in these functions. As I’ve been taking anatomy and physiology recently for my programme, the book served as a nice recap of the brain’s functions and capabilities as well as the physiological role and importance of sleep. At the same time, there’s so much that we still don’t know, so many things that researchers are still investigating.

This volume is very accessible and the information is broken down quite nicely in layman’s terms. I wish the last chapter on how to make the most of your nightly sleep was longer since it’s the most applicable to our everyday lives. Nonetheless, The Secret World of Sleep was an interesting read and I recommend it if you’re into neuroscience, anatomy, science in general or you just want to know more about what goes on when you sleep.

This review was originally posted on caffeinatedlife.net: http://www.caffeinatedlife.net/blog/2013/10/09/review-the-secret-world-of-sleep/

It is unclear who is the intended audience for this book. It's a short read that at first glance appears to be addressed to the common reader, yet it doesn't provide the type of information that would be sought after at the popular level. Neither is it an academic work. Lewis reworks a collection of research material, presumably to make it more accessible to readers, a device that doesn't work in this case. There are some interesting facts, but nothing much that is really useful to the ordinary person in search of knowledge. It is likely that the reader who picks up this book will have sleep problems and hope to find solutions. They will be disappointed.

"When neurons want to communicate one-on-one, they use something called a synapse, a place where the membranes of two different cells come very close together. The receiving side of the synapse is typically loaded with specialist receptors that can bind molecules that float across the synaptic cleft, while the transmitting side is loaded with little vesicles, or bubbles of membranes that encapsulate special chemicals (called neurotransmitters) that can bind to these receptors. When an electric impulse arrives at the transmitting side of the synapse, it triggers feverish activity in these vesicles - they bind to the cell membrane and release their contents into the fluid-filled void that is the synaptic cleft."

If this is the kind of writing you are looking for - or if you want to be bored to sleep - you will probably like this book.

I think I was looking for something more aimed at the general public. This book may be good, but I just couldn't get into it because it kept getting technical. I think I would be interested in what is being discussed - what our minds do when we are asleep, how that plays out with disorders, and how it affects memory, processing,
etc - but I just can't finish the book. Oddly enough, with what I've just said, I was also annoyed that each chapter ended with a paragraph explaining what had just been said in the chapter. The illustrations were a bit odd, although my wife liked the one I showed her that had body parts overlaying parts of the brain.

Way too much clinical/technical jargon to make this book interesting for the general reader. Author Lewis attempts several times to relate interesting anecdotes but consistently bogs them down with too much neuroscience lingo. It was like trying to read a school text. As a matter of fact, there are summaries at the end of each chapter telling you what you should have learned. I was trying to find test answers at the back of the book but I kept falling asleep. So in summary, I guess I did learn something about sleep after all.

This short book presents the what's known so far about sleep, its biology, theories of its purpose, and how to promote it in terms understandable by the layman. It is rather narrowly biological without stepping into theories of consciousness, or philosophy. The various memory studies with rats and humans did reveal some interesting information.

I won this ARC through a Goodreads giveaway. Although a short book, it contains quite a bit of information about what happens to the brain and the body during sleep. The science is explained in such a way that most lay people would understand. I thought it was well researched and personally learned a lot from this book. It has assisted in reminding me to make sleep a priority, which I am guilty of not doing on many occasions. Very happy to have read this interesting and informative book.

What is the purpose of sleep? What goes on in our brains while we sleep? These are the questions explored in this book. I found it fascinating. The author explains different types of sleep and possible purposes behind sleep, including consolidation of learning and memories or dealing with disturbing experiences. She explores links between sleep and different brain disorderers. She includes suggestions for improving sleep, and sleeping more "strategically".

The author explained various scientific studies in a clear way for the general reader. Her book has left me wanting to explore more about the world of sleep.½

Much is being written in magazines and most talk shows have devoted time to the issue of the lack of sleep that people are getting and the increasing need for ways to deal with insomnia. This book explains from a scientific perspective what happens in the brain during sleep and its need for this. It also explains the importance of both slow wave sleep, REM sleep and "swirls" during sleep and their usefulness to our ability to deal with life's challenges. The importance of sleep for regulating emotions, improving memory and skill development, and improving creativity and insight is also explained in terms of scientific studies. The importance of sleep cannot be undervalued. For anyone who is interested in the neural states the brain passes through during sleep and how these benefit us this is a must read. Interesting and informative.½

The author, Penelope Lewis, is the director of the Sleep and Memory Laboratory at the University of Manchester, and here gives a fascinating insight into how our brains continue working while we get some well-deserved rest. I as a former nurse found the anatomy and neurophysiology of the brain very interesting, but to someone without a science or medical background this could become boring, even though she explains the facts in a way that can be fairly easily understood and tries to support the terminology with common real-life analogies. We learn how sleep deprivation can be compared to the effects of alcohol on the brain, and how it affects creativity, lateral thinking, mood and learning. My problem with this book is that the author focuses heavily (almost to the exclusion of everything else) on the consolidation of memories during sleep (not surprisingly, given her job title), and even then some of the results of studies conducted by sleep scientists appear to contradict other results in the same field. As someone who has struggled with sleep issues for more than a decade, I was hoping that there might be some answers in here to explain what's going on in my head at night (or during the day, when I'm desperate for a nap). Only the very last chapter touches on things people with sleep problems could try to achieve a better night's rest, from avoidance of certain foods and caffeine in the evenings or the ambience of the bedroom, to things like timed air fresheners, blue light sources or wearing orange-tinted goggles for a few hours before going to sleep; but then it's probably fair to say that most of the serious insomniacs among us will have tried a good deal of them already, so there's nothing new to be learned in this respect. For a book entitled The Secret World of Sleep: The Surprising Science of the Mind at Rest I was expecting something a little bit more all-encompassing, including a more thorough exploration of sleep disorders; this isn't the author's fault, but – I presume – the publisher's by giving a very specific book a more generic (and hence misleading) title.

(This review was originally written as part of Amazon's Vine programme.)