Photo de l'auteur

Phil Jourdan

Auteur de Praise of Motherhood

3 oeuvres 30 utilisateurs 6 critiques

A propos de l'auteur

Phil Jourdan is a musician, translator and columnist from Portugal, living in the UK.

Œuvres de Phil Jourdan

Praise of Motherhood (2012) 12 exemplaires
What Precision, Such Restraint (2013) 9 exemplaires

Étiqueté

Partage des connaissances

Il n’existe pas encore de données Common Knowledge pour cet auteur. Vous pouvez aider.

Membres

Critiques

I have to admit my feelings about this book were all over the place. I had a lot of trouble getting into the book. Jourdan describes a childhood with a liberal mother who seemingly allowed her children, pets, and staff to do pretty much whatever they chose to do. Jourdan apparently chose to start fires. Frequently and using whatever was on hand or had recently annoyed him. He was a pyromaniac suffering from depression, psychosis, and describes himself as a sociopath. After reading further, though, I do wonder if his social isolation stems more from Asperger's Syndrome than being a sociopath. Not only do I not know the author, but I'm hardly qualified to diagnose such a thing. However, just the possibility made me sympathize more with a person who at first seemed beyond sympathy.

Most of the book is written in a stream-of-consciousness style, with an odd way of switching point-of-view mid-paragraph with no warning. It's also deeper and more philosophical than I usually read. Jourdan gets a little wordy at times, but I can't really complain about that as I've been known to do that a time or two myself while writing.

Jourdan goes off on tangents of fantasy to try to explain the parts of his mother's life with which he is unfamiliar. Almost one full chapter is devoted to the speculation of the life story of a man who may or may not even have existed. Also, the book title seems misleading to me. This book is really about the author and his relationship with his mother is a secondary story line.

About halfway through, the book finally "clicked" for me. Jourdan is brutally honest in describing his feelings. He's angry and he's numb and he's confused. Just as many of are after a tragedy, but are afraid to speak those feelings for fear they'll make us look bad or different. It's very obvious that despite whatever difficulties may have existed between Jourdan and his mother, he loved her deeply. He writes of the numbness he feels in the days after her death, the feeling that it must all be a grand joke that his mother was playing on him and his sister. I especially liked it when he wrote of the time the two of them spent in the kitchen.

"I felt a bond with her stronger than any other, and it was because we were in the kitchen, doing something I cared nothing about in theory, but enjoying it still because we were together and loved each other."

It was heart-breaking to read of his mental breakdowns in his teen years and how terrified he was to tell his mother what was wrong even as he desperately wanted help, but it helped make sense of many things. If I understood correctly, he was only 20-21 years old at the time of her death. This isn't mentioned until close to end of the book, but it actually explains a lot. A typical young man of that age is still in the "selfish" phase. He isn't old enough yet to really cherish his parents and want to take the time to get to know them. After a lifetime of depression and other severe issues, it's hardly surprising that Jourdan didn't know his mother very well. He's still trying to get to know himself.

Chapter 12 is very poignant and what I expected from the whole book when I chose to read it -- except the last section of the chapter, which was just weird and had nothing to do with his mother. And I have to say that the duct tape incident is quite entertaining, considering the context.

Content warning: This book contains a scene depicting child molestation and one line about oral sex with a prostitute (not in the same scene).

I received this book free from the author in exchange for an honest review.
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
amandabeaty | 4 autres critiques | Jan 4, 2024 |
A hard book to rate. I do feel the title and back cover blurb give the wrong expectations. If your interested in reading this, read some reviews to get an idea of what the book is really about. You can visit this extended review at my blog if you're interested: http://neyska.com/2012/07/27/book-review-praise-of-motherhood/.
 
Signalé
NikkiMc | 4 autres critiques | Jun 8, 2017 |
I own this book, and simply could not finish it. I don't know exactly why. I wanted to like it, that's why I applied for the giveaway, but once the book arrived and I started reading, I just had to put it down.

Part of it is that it felt very "dry" in a manner of speaking. It was supposed to be a tribute, it appeared to his mother, but it felt rather emotionless.

I enjoy reading memoirs and wish this had been something I could like.
 
Signalé
Sirsangel | 4 autres critiques | Jan 17, 2015 |
“Chewing the Page: The Mourning Goats Interview” is an interesting look into the world of writers. It is a collection of interviews that were first posted on the website called Mourning Goats. As a person who always likes to look behind the scenes, I was drawn to this book. Some of the authors that were interviewed include Michael Kun, Stephen Elliott, and Chelsea Cain. The authors were asked such questions as “what do you think taught you the most in about writing, and why? Education? Experience? Writing?” and “what are your thoughts about basing characters on real people?”

This book is great for aspiring writers. Writers who have been published seem to have this aura around them that they “made it.” But through these interviews, you find out that it was and still is a lot of hard work to write a good story. You also learn that just because you get a book published doesn’t mean you can quit your day job.

I enjoyed reading the interviews and liked that compilation didn’t just include the serious side of writing and authors, but also included the private and oftentimes silly side.

**I received this book through GoodReads First Reads Giveaway. This did not influence my review.**
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
HeatherMS | Jul 28, 2013 |

Statistiques

Œuvres
3
Membres
30
Popularité
#449,942
Évaluation
½ 3.4
Critiques
6
ISBN
8
Langues
1