Sybil BrintonCritiques

This book by Sybil Brinton is based on multiple characters from Austen's novels. The audio narration was fine but the circa early 1900s fan-fiction story was lacking something. The character of Lizzie (Elizabeth Bennett) is central to this story, but she didn't come across with the same dry wit portrayed within Austen's Pride and Prejudice. I'd recommend reading all of Austen's original novels first before tackling this one, otherwise the story will be really confusing.

Overall Rating: 3.5 stars
Recommended to: Jane Austen fans

Considered the first “fan“ Austen novel as well as pastiche, I enjoyed the attempt by Brinton to include most every main/minor character from all of Austen's novels. However, there were a ton of characters to keep track of, and some were only mentioned briefly. I also found Kitty to be a brat and not remotely ready to fall in love. Still, I loved reading with my bookclub group!

People who are looking for a sequel with lots of Darcy and Elizabeth banter will probably be disappointed, but otherwise, this was a fun book. It was the first published Austen sequel, written in 1913, and the author took characters from all of Jane Austen's novels and imagined new romances and mischief for the ones who were left unmarried in the originals. For the most part, I liked what she did with the characters, and it was a delightful story in the spirit of a Jane Austen novel. My only complaint is that the beginning seemed jumbled, with some awkward dialogue, but once the plot got going, it was an enjoyable read.

A sequel that includes many of the characters from all of Austen's finished works. Though concentrating on the Darcys, the Colonel, and Kitty Bennet who still is as foolish. Elizabeth still can't sketch a character as she befriends Mary Crawford. I disliked her pairing, as she is totally unworthy of him, and how strange that in a sequel only four of the Bennet daughters were mentioned.
Enjoyable enough, though I can't imagine reading it again.

A really enjoyable sequel to the Austen world. Quick predicable, but a fun time.

After ploughing through a handful of Jane Austen spin-offs, good and bad, how could I possibly resist 'the first Jane Austen sequel ever created'? Published in 1913, obscure English author Sybil G. Brinton gathered together a select company of old friends and familiar faces from Jane Austen's novels, from the Darcys and Bingleys of Pride and Prejudice to Mary Crawford and William Price of Mansfield Park and the Wentworths of Persuasion, for what is partly a satisfying if obvious update on the original stories, but also a faithful and well-written romance in its own right.

Set three years after the happy conclusion of Pride and Prejudice, Brinton's sequel mainly concerns the Darcy family, including Lady Catherine, Colonel Fitzwilliam and Georgiana, and follows them from Bath to London to Pemberley, where they meet a host of secondary characters from the other novels. Respectful of Jane Austen's creations, Brinton adds little to the lives of the characters, beyond what Austen herself suggested in family letters and the obvious natural developments that occur after marriage - the Darcys have two children, barely mentioned, and the Bingleys have at least two sons, referred to near the end of the book.

Wherein lies my personal quibble with this sequel, which is otherwise a perfect complement to Austen's limited body of works. Parallel novels and pastiches of classic novels serve one basic purpose - to indulge the imagination of devoted readers by supplying fresh insight into beloved characters, whether by answering the tempting question of 'what happens next?', or revisiting old ground from a different perspective. I can appreciate both requirements, if the sequel is well-written, which this is. Yet no author could successfully fit all of the characters from six different novels, set at different times, into one seamless continuation, without losing either clarity or sympathy. Sybil Brinton does not try, and the result is a purely subjective interest in what I surmise to be her own favourite characters - Darcy and Elizabeth, the bashful Colonel and gentle Georgiana, and of course the ever-hopeful Kitty Bennet, next in line to be paired off; a nervous and repentant Mary Crawford from Mansfield Park, with Fanny's honourable younger brother William Price; and a round-up of the dullest supporting cast from Mansfield Park, Northanger Abbey, Persusasion, and Sense and Sensibility. I was waiting with anticipation to read how my favourite families might have fared, but was sadly disappointed. Mr Knightley is referred to as 'grave', 'terrifying' and 'alarming', and only gets to speak in the next to last chapter, while his wife Emma has grown into a selfish Mrs Jennings figure; whereas Marianne Dashwood, seemingly not as well liked by Brinton as Elinor, is only mentioned in passing, and the poor Colonel has 'passed' altogether! Yet dependable and dutiful Anne Elliot-Wentworth of Persuasion has her praises sung from the rooftops, ridiculous Mrs Jennings of Sense and Sensibility is somehow more important to Elinor than her beloved sister, and all the women have become staid and sensible matrons, matchmaking their younger relatives. I haven't even read Mansfield Park and Persuasion yet, which is my own fault, but I wasn't interested in half of what was going on, and didn't care for the featured characters.

If, like Sybil Brinton, slow and steady wins the day for you, and Colonel Fitzwilliam is not just Darcy's less attractive cousin, or Georgiana his sheltered sister, then I heartily recommend Old Friends and New Fancies. Writing only one hundred years after Austen, and just before the social upheaval of the First World War, Brinton effortlessly captures the style and substance of the original novels. Both wordy and witty ('Nowadays it is the fashion to admire loudest what one understands least'), she understands perfectly the flawless elegance and acute observations of the writing that inspired her, and also adopts a few of Austen's dramatic devices - misdirected attentions, second thoughts, and even a sickbed reunion - which will delight Austen's fans. A livelier cross section of characters would have entertained me more, but perhaps I shall return to Brinton after reading Mansfield Park, and alter my opinion!

Who was this mysterious Sybill G. Brinton? History records very little about her more than her dates of birth and death. She was childless and no known photograph of her exists! What a shame she never wrote anything else. I found her book to be delightful. All the major Jane Austen characters are back and no one, by the end of the book, remains single. Because this book was written in 1913 (says so on the cover), the turn of phrase and general style is much more like Jane's than anything these modern day Jane Wannabe's come up with. But being so much closer to our time, the prose is very comfortable for the modern reader. I found the book to be very pleasant and never ridiculous. I highly recommend this to any fan of Jane Austen. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

I admit it: I'm a purist. I view continuations, additions, and fanfictions with a skeptical eye; very few ever approach the brilliance of the original. I suppose it is natural to want the stories we love to continue, and because I've felt that desire myself I can forgive those who pick up the pen themselves to see to it. Before I say anything else, I'll freely confess my own inability do it creditably, and so I applaud Sybil Brinton's courage. She did not fail, though I would say the achievement is mixed.

Old Friends And New Fancies, published in 1913, is the first attempt at a sequel to Jane Austen's body of work — and probably one of the most ambitious to date. In it Brinton brings together the main characters from all six of Austen's novels, adding a few of her own here and there. The story focuses on several key characters, whose adventures and misadventures in love are explored until we reach the happy ending requisite to this type of work.

Honestly, I'm still trying to decide what to think of it. It was just such a strange experience, to have Austen's various worlds collide in one enormous story. It is interesting which characters are portrayed favorably and which aren't. Emma, for instance, is still fumbling around trying to match up the wrong people and is entirely oblivious to what's really happening — not a sympathetic character at all! While quasi-villains like Mary Crawford are suddenly upgraded to full-fledged heroine status, romantic misunderstandings and all. Still trying to digest that one... it was hard to accept her apparent transformation.

There is a sense of crammedness, of Brinton trying to make room for everybody in her recreation. Austen peopled her novels with such a varied cast of wonderful characters that it would be impossible to include them all and give each sufficient stage time. It's fairly obvious who Brinton's favorites are.

Every now and then the language is reminiscent of Austen, and in a few places it is particularly good. Overall there are no dreadful blunders on that score. But in other places I noticed the elegance of Austen's prose simply isn't there, and there is little that is really memorable in the phrasing, insights, or relational dynamics.

I do appreciate Brinton's note at the beginning, part of which states:

The difficulties, as well as the presumption, of such an undertaking, are alike evident; but the fascination of the subject must be our apology to those who, like ourselves, "owe to Jane Austen of the happiest hours of their lives."

With an apology like that, how can we be angry at Brinton? She didn't include anything inappropriate to Austen's period, characters, and moral tone, which is not such a given as one might think in books that continue the stories of Austen's characters. Indeed, most of the stuff being churned out nowadays with the "Austen-sequel" label on it is nothing more than soft-core porn, Regency style. Bleccchh.

I think I'll need to read this again before I can form a definitive opinion. It is only at great cost that purists unbend; I am sure other purists in the room will comprehend the concession. A brave attempt, Ms. Brinton, and one that is not altogether unsuccessful as an amusing diversion for Austen's many devotees.½

I loved this charming book. It brings all of her characters together in one story. It is amazing to see what this author things the characters would do and who the single ones married. This is a lovely book.

It was interesting to read the first Austen sequel but it was rather difficult to figure out who was who. There were a lot of characters who all somehow knew each other. In the start of the book there is a page that tells who all the original Austen characters are that Brinton includes in her story and it is quite a long list. I ended up just trying to get into the plot without placing all the characters in my mind. I could tell that Brinton really put effort into keeping the characters true to their natures as described by Austen. Another positive for me was that the writing style was quite authentic to the time period. Being written in 1913, it was at least a bit closer to the original writing style than the sequels being written today. The cover is really lovely and the story was sweet if a little unrealistic. For someone who is thoroughly familiar with all of Austen's novels, Old Friends and New Fancies would be really enjoyable.

Okay, so let it be said that I am generally against posthumous sequels and never more so than when it comes to Jane Austen. I like an honest homage (like Hale's Austenland, which was hilarious), but those overblown romance novels that have recently been capitalizing on the good name of Darcy annoy the crap out of me, and the past several years of increasing Austen-trendiness have only increased the number and decreased the quality of such bodice-rippers-in-disguise (not that there is anything wrong with a good bodice-ripper -- it just bothers me when they pretend to be anything like Austen and then those lofty literary aspirations turn out to be mere marketing). When it comes to Brinton's sequel, however, I made a conscious exception for particular reasons: first, because this is not a recent sequel -- it was published in 1913, the centenary of the publication of Pride and Prejudice and was recently reissued; second, related to earlier statements, is that this novel actually attempts to write in the style and within the parameters of Jane Austen... it actually tries to be a sequel in her spirit, rather than a reader's wet dream; and finally, that this novel doesn't just follow the marriage of Elizabeth and Fitzwilliam Darcy -- the chosen fantasy premise of most nouveau-Austenites -- but instead takes characters from all six of Austen's completed novels and interweaves them into a new story of matchmaking and -breaking.

Of course, this doesn't mean that Brinton achieves the shimmering brilliance of Austen's style -- many moments in the text seem too forced, rather than simply echoing the natural formality of the era, though others are bright and enjoyable, especially once things get rolling -- but the fact that she gives it a genuine try enables the reader to gloss over the moments where she falls short. Also apparent is Brinton's great and sincere love for Austen's work and her intent to do justice to the author who has inspired her; as a reader and a fellow fan, I appreciate her appreciation, as well as her authenticity.

Along with the style, the action of the story offers much to satisfy an Austen fan. Some of the lesser characters of whom we wanted to know more in the original texts are expanded here. Some of the character changes are a little unlikely and may jar with modern audiences used to Austen film adaptations -- Mary Crawford, for example, is a great deal more sympathetic here than I think she ever could have been within Austen's world -- but generally the characters consistently reflect the attitudes and attributes with which their original creator endowed them. Those who are matched, even across previous textual borders, fit well and many will make the familiar reader smile with some satisfaction.

Overall, I truly enjoyed the book, even with its limitations and even as a posthumous sequel. Brinton, from her now distant 20th century milieu, reaches out with a measure of humility and a pleasantly frank sense of joy to offer up this continuation of an experience she enjoyed so well herself. I can appreciate her motivations and their result equally well.

One addendum: I would be curious to know how the novel comes across to those who have not read Austen extensively -- there were times as I read that I got distracted thinking back to Austen's original novels, trying to recall a detail or action, and it was a little bit of a struggle to pull myself back to the story at hand. Would those who were not huge fans of Austen have as difficult a time? Would the novel stand on its own without the context of the originals? The world may never know, since those who have not read Austen are utterly unlikely to pick up this book. :)½

As a complete sucker for all things Jane Austen, need I say that the idea of reading the very first "sequel" to Pride and Prejudice was an appealing one to me? Even better than that was dicovering that this is more than just a Pride and Prejudice sequel. As its newly minted subtitle claims, it is a sequel to all the novels. Pulling many favorite characters from all of Austen's best-loved works, Brinton has created a fun romp through Regency England in the company of Austen's secondary characters.

This is not focused on the main characters of Aussten's books. After all, she wrapped their stories up fairly neatly. Instead, the focus is on Georgiana Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliam, Kitty Bennett and Mary Crawford, Tom Bertram and William Price, and others. While some purists shudder at the thought of introducing these characters to each other, Regency society was fairly small and so people of the same social standing could be expected to have connections to each other, making this intermingling of Austen's creations feasible.

The plot, while not as witty and sharp as Austen's herself, is quite entertaining, opening with Georgiana and Colonel Fitzwilliam breaking their engagement to each other to the stern annoyance of Lady Catherine. Both will look for suitable partners throughout the rest of the book. Each will have to overcome societal obstacles as well as the difficulties of their own hearts and personalities in order to be happy.

As with most Austen sequels, a reader who is not familiar with the backstory and characters from the originals will be disappointed with the novel. But Austen fans who are willing to allow the mingling of their best-loved minor characters will likely enjoy this short and quick read.

If you're a fan of all of Jane Austen's books, then this is a MUST read. Brinton took characters from Austen's books and wrote a really fun sequel that is very similar to Austen in style. Of course, it has a happy ending with deserving couples finding marriage. IF you haven't read all of Austen's books, you might want to do that before you read this one. There are TONS of characters from her books in here and it could get really confusing if you aren't already familiar with them.