Trevor ScottCritiques

Very intriguing reboot of the Earth-2 characters with some great shifts/changes to 70 year old characters. My biggest question was why the cover so prominently places DC's Big Three when they're all gone from the story after 20 pages. Still, with some reservations, I highly recommend this work from this promising start.

867

1559

This started out really dark and then became about the gathering of a new Justice League on an alternate earth. Art was cool, characters were decent, looks like the line-up will probably be Green Lantern, Flash, Atom, and Hawkgirl, but they're not actually "together" yet.

Excellent retelling of the alternate earth that isn't quite the same as the Earth-1 we're all familiar with. I especially liked the new origin stories of Golden Age Flash and Green Lantern, and how they worked in a new story for Hawkgirl and The Atom.

This is a writer's dream, being able to take known characters and changing things up, sometimes very drastically. It's almost like reading the old Elseworlds imprint DC used to publish back in the 90s.

Very intriguing reboot of the Earth-2 characters with some great shifts/changes to 70 year old characters. My biggest question was why the cover so prominently places DC's Big Three when they're all gone from the story after 20 pages. Still, with some reservations, I highly recommend this work from this promising start.

Access a version of the below that includes illustrations on my blog.

At the end of Identity Crisis, Atom Ray Palmer vanished-- and given what had happened to him, it's hard to complain. The All New Atom follows the adventures of Ryan Choi, a young Ph.D. from Hong Kong who takes Palmer's place at Ivy University, Ivy Town, as a professor of nuclear physics. Choi was a correspondent of the Atom from a young age, and of course doesn't just take Palmer's place in the laboratory/classroom, but soon finds himself stepping into the role of the Atom.

The basic premise of this book is excellent. As an academic, I like that the book is not only set in a college town, but uses that-- Choi's best friend is another professor, and Choi is supported technologically by a group of professors who get together to play poker and complain about things. The Dean is a key character in the book. (That said, apparently the Dean of this university hires professors without campus visits!) I especially like the idea that years of wacky happenings have totally rewritten the laws of physics within Ivy Town.

Also there are some good academic jokes, such as when Ryan tells the villain of this volume, "There's a war going on. If magic wins, they'll end science forever. You can't want that, right?" and the other guy replies, "Oh, well, to be honest, I don't much about that. See, I'm actually a philosophy major."

Plus John Byrne pencils most of the book, and you can almost never beat Byrne on a superhero book. Clear storytelling, good facial expressions, bold action. I also liked Simone's device of placing quotations (mostly from scientists, real and fictional) juxtaposed with the dialogue, a nice comics-dependent device.

Unfortunately, the book's actually story remained too muddled for me to get into it. What exactly was at stake in the weird war between cancer and tiny people? What did the Dean and a serial killer have to do with it all? Why was there all of a sudden a threat to the President that was resolved just as quickly? Why would the Dean call in the father of a professor he's worried about-- and how on Earth could the father of a professor make him go home? I just never really got the relationships between a lot of what was going on throughout most of the book, making for a confusing and disappointing reading experience. Hopefully future volumes deliver on the strong premise of this series.

The Atom: « Previous in sequence | Next in sequence »

While this was not the Earth-Two I grew up with in the 70's, I like the reimagining of these classic characters in a new, exciting way. The story was solid and the art was fantastic.

A young CIA officer follows a STASI (East German) assassin to Iceland. An upcoming summit between Reagan and Gorbachev is soon to take place. Who is the target.

A mystery with spies. Spine-tingling with beautiful scenery and a short travelogue on Iceland.½

very different take on what's going on in the dcu and reintroducing the jsa. i am intrigued to read more.

I wanted to like this book much more than I actually did. I thought the opening premise was ballsy, and had so much potential. Then in issue 2...

...they go to the trouble of making an established character gay, and immediately kill off his love interest, effectively neutering him.

The reimaginings of the Green and the Rot were interesting, but suffer from superhero over-exaggeration. Seriously, tone it down a notch? Not everything has to be cataclysmic to be entertaining.

Normally I enjoy James Robinson's writing, and I thought Nicola Scott's art was fantastic. But I'm not sold on this series, and I'm not sure I'll continue reading.½

Trent Strong is a Pulitzer nominated journalist from Chicago who moves back to his hometown to run the local newspaper he has purchased.

Lots of action related to his old high school girlfriend who is murdered a day before she is to meet with him.