Tal McThenia

The story of Bobby Dunbar is remarkable for many reasons and it is told sometimes brilliantly, and sometimes painfully slowly, in "A Case for Solomon."
The details here can be exceptionally tedious; it's as though the writer wants to make use of every single bit of research he unearthed (and his research is, indeed, impressive). The problem is that it makes for text that feels heavy, just one small step above an entry in an encyclopedia. Scenes that the reader is waiting for, that offer critical information about the story, are long and labored and become dreary instead of exciting. (Imagine watching a marathon and, in the last minutes having to see it in slow motion, and also hearing at the same time information about the kinds of shoes the runner is wearing, and where he bought his clothing, and his favorite foods.) The details about the role of the newspapers could make a book in themselves, and are rarely all that compelling.
Most people know the results of the DNA tests, so there are no great revelations here. But I still picked up this book because I wanted to know more about the family, and especially about the man who grew up as Bobby Dunbar.
I loved the beginning and the end, and many parts in the middle. If only this book had had a competent editor it could have been masterful.… (plus d'informations)

This is one of those books that sticks with you for a while. I was horrified to learn the role the press played in this whole fiasco. We really have not learned from past mistakes. When Bobby Dunbar went missing, no stone was left unturned. Yet when a boy was found who was similar in looks, the press was there to “get the story”. I felt like they were willing to make the story fit a happy ending no matter what.
My sympathies went to Julia Anderson who had no resources due to her financial circumstances. I was pleased to learn the truth had been found but saddened by the pain everyone involved in this case suffered. The authors have done a tremendous amount of research and have successfully told the story in a way that carried the reader along, making them want to know what happened next.

We are given a look at the time period and how things worked for those who had and those had not. In this day and age we have the benefit of DNA testing. Yet I wonder how much the press would be able to skew the opinions of all parties involved. It is sad that so many lives have been destroyed. Yet I feel that a mystery was left unanswered in this story. I don’t know if anyone will ever solve that mystery. This is definitely worth the read.… (plus d'informations)

As someone who is intimately attached to this story (I am married to the grandson of the boy who is the focus of this book) I have to admit, the writing did nothing for me. I was aware there was a story about the blood of the man who is known as Bobby Dunbar. I was aware it was a huge piece of news at the time, becoming a national story. But I also knew that the blood running through the man's veins did not impact who he was as a husband or a father.

The writing of this book was stilted and dense. I found it tough to get through, as there were so many pieces of data that were incorporated into the narrative. Perhaps that makes it a stronger non-fiction book, delving into the nitty gritty of a story that rocked communities and families intimately. However, it also means that the audience for this book today, is small and intimate and will likely not reach a much wider piece of the population.

To be fair, I am generally a lover of fiction, where the theme is the key, not the evidence. Though, when I do reach for non-fiction, the thesis statement is something I generally look for, and I could not find it in the amassed pile of references here. Perhaps I didn't dig enough, or pay enough attention. I'll take some ownership of the disconnect between myself and the book.… (plus d'informations)