W. Warde FowlerCritiques
Auteur de Social Life at Rome in the Age of Cicero
25+ oeuvres 203 utilisateurs 5 critiques
Critiques
Social life at Rome in the Age of Cicero par W. Warde Fowler
Signalé
aine.fin | Mar 15, 2016 | One might wonder how useful a book originally published in 1899 is today. This book has been repeatedly reissued. H. H. Scullard, in the introduction to his 1981 book Festivals and Ceremonies of the Roman Republic, singled out Fowler's book as a particularly valuable resource despite its age, writing, "I have not been so presumptuous as to attempt to provide an alternative." (see Wikipedia, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Warde_Fowler). The book is certainly not a primer on Roman religion: the author assumes a certain knowledge of Rome. Moreover, his quotations are left in the original language, whether Latin, Greek, German, etc.
Fowler works his way through the Roman year, beginning with the original first month, March. Using the fragments of calendars that have come down to us, as well as historic and literary references, he attempts to understand the various festivals. He quotes other modern sources, and weighs their arguments. Fowler assumes that the oldest festival were tied to agriculture, and their meaning changed and their importance receded as Rome became a large city. By the end of the Republican era, even the Romans were unsure of the meaning of some of their festivals. He is quite frank that there are limits to our knowledge: "There are festivals within the calendar about which we really know nothing at all, and must frankly confess our ignorance; there are others of which we know just enough to be doubtful ... ."
Although it requires Fowler's polyglot capabilities (or a good library of translations) to get full value from this book, I felt that I learned a great deal even though I could only read the English.
Fowler works his way through the Roman year, beginning with the original first month, March. Using the fragments of calendars that have come down to us, as well as historic and literary references, he attempts to understand the various festivals. He quotes other modern sources, and weighs their arguments. Fowler assumes that the oldest festival were tied to agriculture, and their meaning changed and their importance receded as Rome became a large city. By the end of the Republican era, even the Romans were unsure of the meaning of some of their festivals. He is quite frank that there are limits to our knowledge: "There are festivals within the calendar about which we really know nothing at all, and must frankly confess our ignorance; there are others of which we know just enough to be doubtful ... ."
Although it requires Fowler's polyglot capabilities (or a good library of translations) to get full value from this book, I felt that I learned a great deal even though I could only read the English.
Signalé
PuddinTame | Mar 21, 2011 | Obviously, I am a fan of the books of W. Warde Fowler. I first encountered one of his books in 1970. This book, ROME, saved my life at the time. I was due to start teaching a course in two days' time as a T.A. and I needed a departure point. This book gave me an overview and an insight into Rome such as I had never quite had in much more detailed books about the subject. Fowler cut through to the facts and principles which the Republic and the Empire were subject to and, as I said before, made my life much easier. I have since discovered all of his other writings and it is wonderful to encounter such a scholar of the old school with such wide-ranging knowledge and interests.
Signalé
rwhitnjapan | 1 autre critique | Feb 3, 2010 | Signalé
zinf | Jul 22, 2008 | Edition: Second Edition // Descr: 168 p. 17 cm. // Series: The Home University Library Call No. { 947 F43 } Series No. 42 Series Edited by Michael Abercrombie and A.D. Woozley Revised by M.P. Charlesworth Contains Bibliography and Index. // //
Signalé
ColgateClassics | 1 autre critique | Oct 26, 2012 | Liens
Wikipedia (English)
LT character page. (English)
Ce site utilise des cookies pour fournir nos services, optimiser les performances, pour les analyses, et (si vous n'êtes pas connecté) pour les publicités. En utilisant Librarything, vous reconnaissez avoir lu et compris nos conditions générales d'utilisation et de services. Votre utilisation du site et de ses services vaut acceptation de ces conditions et termes.