Stephen BrumwellCritiques

A great look at the reasons that led Benedict Arnold to betray his country. The author tells of motives other than money that ultimately caused Benedict to decide to side with the British and attempt to let West Point fall into enemy hands. Also gives a nice follow up to Benedict's life after returning to England.

When I think of the American “frontier” what usually comes to mind is the “Wild West”; during the mid-18th century the “frontier” included Connecticut and upstate New York. The seacoast held English colonists but the entire interior of the continent belonged to the French and Native Americans. In the North American conflicts that spilled over from European wars, it took English commanders a long time – sometimes never – to realize that the linear tactics, disciplined volley fire, and bayonet charges that worked so well in Europe were completely ineffective in the deep woods. After some bloody defeats the more perceptive English commanders realized that they needed light infantry that could operate there; with some class-conscious reluctance a colonial officer, Robert Rogers, was allowed to organize a company of eponymous Rangers that could take the war to the enemy – or at least figure out where the enemy was.

After achieving renown in the French and Indian War, Roger’s fame diminished – likely because he picked the wrong (Loyalist) side in the American Revolutionary War. He came back to public attention with the 1937 fictionalized biography Northwest Passage, later made into a movie (with Spencer Tracy as Rogers) and a TV series (with Buddy Ebsen). The actual fighting was considerably sanitized for Hollywood, of course. Which finally brings us to the book review – Stephen Brumwell’s White Devil. Brumwell is not politically correct in his treatment of Native Americans – they pillage, rape, murder, and torture. However, he makes it clear that the white people they were fighting also pillaged, raped, murdered and tortured; we just got to write that out of the histories.

Although Brumwell extensively covers Rogers Rangers earlier actions, the centerpiece of the book is Roger’s October 1759 raid on the Abenaki village of St. Francis, in what’s now Quebec. The Rangers reached the town after a boat journey up Lake Champlain and an overland trek; the attack was carefully planned to take place at dawn, with sharpshooters posted at exit routes and the main body sweeping through the town to burn, kill, and loot. The Abenaki seem to have received some warning that the attack was coming but if so were tragically unprepared; the warriors were elsewhere and Roger’s men – despite orders – killed the elderly, the women, and the children that remained in St. Francis. The subsequent retreat was even more heroic/antiheroic than the attack. Rogers feared a pursuing force was close behind – this wasn’t correct, but his boats had been discovered where he had left them at Lake Champlain and an ambush was waiting there. He therefore made the right decision for the wrong reasons – to take another, much longer route back to friendly territory. This turned into an epic; the retreating raiders divided into small parties and some of them were caught and slaughtered. The others suffered grimly from starvation and exposure – and in one case killed and ate one of their Abenaki captives (She was described as “plump”). To compound the misery, a relief party that was supposed to cache supplies gave up and abandoned their mission just two hours before the Rangers would have reached them. The surviving Rangers eventually reached Connecticut; despite the decimation of the Ranger force the raid was hailed as a great victory. Brumwell notes that the Abenaki still call Rogers “Wobomagonda” – White Devil.

Rogers’ subsequent career was anticlimactic; unlike many of his Ranger compatriots – notably John Stark, hero of the Battle of Bennington – Rogers stayed Loyalist during the American Revolution but didn’t perform any notable service. After the war he went to England but was unable to obtain any preferment, and sunk into gambling and drink, eventually dying, deeply in debt, in 1795.

Brumwell’s book is fascinating, an easy read and full of details about life on the frontier and in the military. There are extensive endnotes – but they are not indexed by page. No bibliography, but the relevant works are all referenced in the endnotes. Maps show the general colonial situation, and details of the advance and retreat from St. Francis. There’s a handy appendix with the names of all the principal actors, and another appendix with Rogers’ Rules to be observed in the ranging service (still in use by the US Army Rangers).

Excellent history of the French Indian Wars and the role that Robert Rogers played in the fight. Also a look at the Abenaki Indians which inhabited New England during the wars.

An excellent well-written reference book for any serious student of Georgian Britain.

The stereotypical impression of the British soldier during the Seven Years' War is one of a low-born, resentful, downtrodden military automaton, not especially well led by his officers, and barely kept in line by a harsh code of capricious justice. One only need recall the portrayal of British soldiery in recent films such as The Patriot (2000) or Last of the Mohicans (1992) to understand how these negative stereotypes have survived to the present era. Stephen Brumwell means to change the commonly held perception that the world of the redcoated British soldier was "nasty, brutish, and short." This perception, according to Brumwell, has been so thoroughly ingrained in historical memory that ultimate British success in North America during the Seven Years' War "continues to be attributed to anything but the prowess of the British Army."
Brumwell's main argument is that the experience of the British soldier in North America was much more complex than has been previously supposed. In fact, this book makes an excellent supporting companion to Fred Anderson's more comprehensive Crucible of War: The Seven Years' War and the Fate of Empire in British North America (2000). In nine succinct chapters, Brumwell traces the evolution of redcoats' experience in North America and reveals that they played a very direct and effective role in winning a North American empire for the crown.

Dr. Peter Way