Caleb’s story was one I was excited yet hesitant about because I loved his character in the other books and his playful side, yet I knew he was struggling with things in his life. He is a total player, and I was ok with that because he is still young, hasn’t found anyone that he sparks with, and he is just living his life on his own terms. In this story Caleb, Eli, and Gracie all become roommates, Gracie and Caleb clash because she can’t stand his playboy ways, yet she was exactly like him. Gracie is a total player too not wanting to settle down like their friends, yet Caleb bothered her because it was like looking in the mirror. This part was hard for me to connect or like Gracie because she had double standards of how Caleb lived his life when she was the same. I wanted to like her, yet she came off as hard, shallow, and it was too much for me. Caleb was playful and a total player, but I wanted someone with him that could help him and be as playful back. This book was a good one and this series has been amazing, and I did like seeing the characters grow I just wish I had connected with Gracie more. Can they change their ways let each other in or will they continue this hate/attraction fighting they have going? The ending had my heart shattering and I wanted to cry so bad because I love the characters it was affecting, and they had already been through so much and now we must wait and see how their story plays out or if it will even have a happy ending. While I did enjoy this story, I found myself loving Caleb more than Gracie and I’m dying for the next one now, I just know the wait will slowly kill my heart. ( )