I ended up with this book along with a number of others from a relative's collection.
From the description, I was really looking forward to this book. Unfortunately, it was a bit of a let down. I'm not sure exactly what I was expecting, but it was definitely not what I got.
I suppose I anticipated a bit more of the 'mystic detective' trope, ala Carnacki or so many other examples from weird and pulp fiction. And that's certainly present in a way...but there is an awful lot of almost Victorian/Romantic-esque nobility/rich person stuff here. Much like a lot of classic literature from that era, I find it a little off-putting. Its hard to feel sympathetic to or identify with people so wealthy they have no actual responsibilities or demands on their time. Even artists who benefit from their patronage (which are present here) feel similar to me. Combined with the fact that we get *VERY LIMITED* magic or mystical secret society action until about the last 50 pages of this book. In fact, there's very little action of any kind til that point. Until then, there's a lot meandering not really training, not really teaching, a new protege...a lot of description of rich people's homes and cars and oh so important activities, a *little* investigation...and that's about it. There's also some really heavy christian overtones to the magic, which I wasn't anticipating, but the author goes out of their way to let us know it doesn't *have* to be that way. Unless someone tells me the subsequent books have a pretty hard shift in tone and pacing, I'm out for the rest of the series. ( )

It's a very interesting story. Again, I've read it many times before, so I largely knew what would happen ahead of time, but it's a very rich story and I see new things each time I read it. Peregrine is a very handy mechanism for the authors to explain all the mystic, esoteric stuff to their readers. He's also an interesting person, and I find his reactions to a lot of what he learns both realistic and amusing. The enemy are presented as irredeemably evil and also rather pettily cruel (or perhaps just careless, but it comes to the same result). I enjoy all the ordinary bits of the story, too - the weather, Templemor, their food, Humphrey...the magical bits fit in, and the combination makes for a very convincing world. We get some hints Adam et al don't - some names, mostly - though by the end of the book it's clear that Adam knows things we don't, yet, about the enemy. He's encountered the Lynx symbol before... Good story both as a self-contained adventure and as the intro to the series. I do like Adam - and Peregrine, and Neil, and Lady Laura, and just about everyone (who isn't a bad guy) that we meet. ( )

Very good beginning to a non-Deryni series ( )

http://allbookedup-elena.blogspot.com/2008/12/adept-katherine-kurtz-and-deborah.... ( )

Fascinating tale with Masonic overtones, romance, and Scotland. ( )