This is the first Titchmarsh novel I have read and I borrowed it from the Library on the strength of having read one of Alan Titchmarsh's gardening books. I really enjoyed it although it has prompted me to ask lots of questions of myself about why.

There were aspects of the novel which were predictable such as 'the wicked stepmother' character Charlottwe Niven. But on the other hand it was just a family story which was very engaging.

It is set in the Scottish Highlands and one learns a lot about being a landowner from the background. Titchmarsh's representation of the Scottish accent seems authentic but perhaps others might feel differently.

I think this is the key thing about the novel - it feels authentic as though the author knows what he is talking about which leads to the inevitable question - is it at all autobiographical in any way?

Funnily enough there is not a mention of gardens in the novel!!

I liked the way each chapter began with a wise saying or quotation. This gave one something to think on before the chapter began.

I did not like the ending and the way the step-mother was written out of the story - it seemed contrived . On the other hand the imagery of the golden swan I found quite believable.

A good but I guess not a taxing read.