Poppy Shakespeare (2006)

The Dorothy Fish is a psychiatric hospital in London. N – the narrator of the book – has been a patient there for 13 years, and like the other patients, her ambition is to never be discharged. So when a new patient named Poppy Shakespeare arrives, furious at being sent there, claiming that she doesn’t have any psychiatric problems, and determined to get out, N is confused by Poppy’s attitude. Nevertheless, the two become friends, and N tries to help Poppy prove that she does not belong in the hospital. But they soon realise that they are up against ludicrous bureacracy and a system that hinders those it is meant to help.

I had high hopes for this book – one of the quotes on the cover describes it as a cross between One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest, and Catch 22 – praise indeed! Unfortunately, while it definitely has some qualities to recommend it, I found that it fell short of my expectations.

As a narrator, N was unreliable, and I could never be sure whether she was telling things the way they happened, or the way she imagined them. This was probably part of the point however, and I had absolutely no problem with it. Certainly some of the things she claimed to witness seemed too ridiculous to actually be real, but despite her self-centredness and her skewed take on events, she was quite an endearing character. The whole book is told through her eyes, and using her vernacular (“I’m not saying nothing, but you know what I’m saying?!”) She was also very funny at times (unintentionally on the part of the character, but surely intentionally on the part of the author).

One of the things that became apparent quite early on was how each patient (known as ‘dribblers) had a name that represented a letter of the alphabet – and it seemed only possible for anyone to admitted to the Dorothy Fish when the previous patient with that initial had left (for example, Poppy was admitted to the hospital, after Pollyanna had left). I assumed that this was the author’s way of making the point that the health services saw them only as statistics rather than as actual people. And that illustrates part of the problem of the book – it seemed to me that it didn’t know whether it wanted to tell a straight out story, or whether it wanted to be satirical view of the health services.

The ending was also unsatisfactory, at least from my point of view, and never really resolved the questions in my mind – which may have been deliberate, but was certainly irritating. Certain parts of the plot didn’t make any sense – the process that led to Poppy being sent to the hospital in the first place for instance, but as we only have N’s account of how that happened, it’s impossible to know how much of it was true.

On the plus side, as I have already mentioned, it did have a number of very funny parts, and despite the problems, was very readable. Other than the narrator herself however, it never seemed that any of the other characters were really studied, and they were mainly portrayed as broad stereotypes – again, possibly as a result of N’s view of them, but either way it didn’t work for me.

Having said all that, I probably would pick up another book by Clare Allan – she has a flair for humour and the writing flowed well. Overall, it wasn’t a raging disappointment, but it didn’t live up to the rave reviews which I had read. ( )

When I started this book I thought I was in for a treat, as it received many raving reviews. N's language quickly became annoying tough (Do you know what I'm saying)
All of the characters, apart from Poppy Shakespeare, were thoroughly unlikable, I wonder what the writer means to imply here about people with mental heatlh issues.
In the end I just grew tired of the book and kept counting how many pages were still left. Admittedly Poppy's story was very interesting and this was what kept me reading, but for me it didn't make up for the rest of the book.
Whatever point the writer was trying to make about British psychiatry, to me she just comes across as very harsh on anyone suffering from mental illness.
Also the idea that patients make up symptoms so as not to be discharged comes across as ludicrious to anyone who has ever spend time inside a psychiatric hospital - as I read the author has. ( )

I so wanted to like this book, from the blurb on the back it sounded interesting. I just didn't get it - I didn't like the way it was written, I didn't find it particularly amusing, in fact I thought it was sad. I know it was supposed to be a parody, but I do think there is probably more than a grain of truth in the story, and that what happened to Poppy and N could actually happen to some extent within the British Mental Health system.

I struggled to keep my attention on the book whilst reading it, and found myself easily distracted, which to me is always a sign that I'm not really getting into something! ( )

Poppy Shakespeare : Roman / Clare Allan
Ein Stockwerk entscheidet über das Leben
Poppy Shakespeare ist eine arbeitlose Karrierefrau. Natürlich nutzt sie alle Möglichkeiten um einen neuen Job zu bekommen. Nach einem Einstellungstest wird ihr allerdings kein Job vermittelt, sondern sie wird in eine Tagesklinik gesteckt. Die Dorothy Fish ist eine Nervenheilanstalt im Norden Londons und Poppy ist nicht begeistert. N ist eine langjährige Patientin und wird beauftragt Mrs Shakespeare herum zuführen und sie in die Gruppe ein zubinden. Poppy und N verstehen sich und werden beste Freundinnen. Doch nach einiger Zeit werden immer mehr ihrer Mitmenschen aus der Klinik entlassen. Was wird nun aus Poppy und N. Werden sich ihre Wünsche erfüllen?

Was bedeutet schon normal? In „Poppy Shakespeare“ wird uns vor Augen geführt, das eine kleine Macke schon als Krankheit verkauft werden. Zum Schmunzeln, Lachen und nachdenken. ( )