short and sweet holiday story. h is a bit annoying, but it all works out. ( )

I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Great Scot by Suzanne Enoch 3 stars

“Aye, here we are. A man with a ruined face who tries to imagine perfect buildings, and a lass who enjoys solitude and reading trying to keep track of a busy countess’s social schedule.”

This novella is set in Enoch's series Wild Wicked Highlanders, three highland brothers go to London and wind up finding wives. If you've read that series, you'll recognize Jane, the cousin and former companion to one of the new wives who ended up being thrown out by her aunt because Jane helped her cousin elope with one of the highlander brothers. Jane was welcomed in by the highlander's mother and works as her companion now, even though she's aware it's more of charity than actual necessity.

I felt this novella was the least rushed, in terms of storytelling and romance, but as this was set in an already established world and one I'm familiar with, the author could play off that established knowledge and reader developed feelings. Jane was a sweet character who at 33 years old felt on the shelf and lost a bit in where she belongs in the world. As the family is spending the holidays at Aldriss Park in Scotland, we get some great seasonal reading, chilly and snowy scenes and a highlander cousin for Jane.

Brennan Andrews is a cousin to the MacTaggert brothers, an architect, and a widower. He lost his wife seven years ago and in a town where everyone knew her, no one wants to insult her memory by developing a romance with him. Coll, the oldest MacTaggert, wants him to build a house for him and his new wife and while searching for papers in the library he meets Jane. They're both a little shy and bumbling, Jane is used to staying to the corners and with so many years removed from when he had to romance anyone, Brennan is out of practice and wary because of the patch he wears over one eye due to losing it in a riding accident. The location brings the snowy atmosphere and Jane and Brennan provide the gentle, loving feels.

Christmas at Dewberry Hollow by Amelia Grey 3 stars

Their breaths mingled in the freezing air. Their eyes searched.

Isabelle Reed's family has run the Inn ever since her Viscount ancestor decided to turn one of their home's into a profit inn. Her and her mother have been trying to keep it afloat since her father died and her mother's uncle passed away and the new viscount has cut their allowance. This Christmastime, they are having the Duke of Notsgrove stay and they hope the income of his stay will keep them afloat a little longer. Isabelle has lived her whole life in Dewberry Hollow and can't imagine living anywhere else. She teaches some classes to town's children in exchange for goods to help fill out their meager income. When Isabelle is out hunting, she accidentally shoots a man in the arm, she already feels awful but when she discovers it is the guard of the Duke of Notsgrove's grandson, she is scared she might have jeopardized the inn's income.

While not the heir, John Gatestone still has a close, loving relationship with his cantankerous duke grandfather. His grandfather has been failing lately and the family fears he won't have much longer to live. When his grandfather insists that he must visit the tree he carved his and his late wife's initials in before he dies, John volunteers to take him and promises the family he will have his grandfather back by Christmas dinner. When his guard gets grazed in the arm by a shot, John finds himself drawn to the shooter, Isabelle.

This was snowy and sweet novella that had some quick feeling falling in love. Isabelle has been burnt before by a man her mother loved and Isabelle dearly wanted as a stepfather who promised to return and never did. John has never felt the importance of marrying as he's not the heir. There wasn't too much angsty drama keeping these two apart, John comes up with a deal that he won't tell anyone Isabelle accidentally shot his guard if she helps him look for his grandfather's tree and that plot gives us some scenes of the two together and to help show the attraction between the two.

I thought their love felt quick and I'm not sure I completely bought into the ending in regards to John's decision to upend his life but, like I said, this had sweet vibe and definite winter seasonal atmosphere. It works as a middle story in the anthology to anchor it but also keep up the short burst of romance bargain.

My Mistletoe Beau by Anna Bennett 2.5 stars

Miss Eva Tiding’s hands were surprisingly steady, considering she was on the doorstep of London’s most disreputable rogue. And on the brink of committing a felony.

This one probably had the most story meat to it, Eva sets out to steal a watch that her late mother gave her father and he has now lost in a poker wager. Her father is despondent without it and I kept getting tripped up that he would wager the watch if it meant so much to him. Anyway, she breaks into the Earl of Frostbough's home to steal the watch back and gets caught by him. They do have some fun back and forth, not quite reaching the sizzle of heated by play but the Earl, Jack, says he will not give the watch back for any price. We get some backstory that Eva's late mother was actually to be engaged to Jack's father but she ended up eloping with Eva's eventual father. This left Jack's father hurt and angry and made growing up with him miserable for Jack. He blames Eva's father for this misery.

However, even with this lifetime grudge, Jack thinks of how he has lied to his grandmother that he is in a courtship with a lady, to get her not to worry about him but then she sends him a letter telling him she is going to visit so she can meet the lady. Jack proposes a deal with Eva, if she goes along with the ruse that she is the lady he is in a courtship with and attends three societal functions with him, he will give her the watch back. There's a striptease and then a kiss to see if they can pull off pretending to be courting and this all has Eva scared her heart could be at risk, so she lies to Jack that she could never pretend and refuses the deal. His feelings are hurt but when Eva learns her father is trying to set her up with a marquess, she decides to accept Jack's proposal to keep her own father off her back.

There was just too much in this story that felt off balance to me, the backstory, the setup between Eva and Jack, and Eva deciding that they would act broken up in public but be sleeping with each other behind closed doors later in the story. This was the steamiest of the three reads and while I initially enjoyed the back and forth between these two, it didn't sustain it's chemistry, coming off forced. Jack was pretty much all in and pining (I didn't witness any of the coldhearted/mean reputation he was supposedly known for) for Eva while she is a little more cold shoulder, to wanting him, and then thinking he was playing her for revenge against her father (it doesn't really make sense why she would suddenly think this).

This had more of the snowy atmosphere, a houseparty, and mistletoe to tie it into the holiday collection. While this had more meat to it's story, it felt off balance with it's components not always fitting together right for me. ( )

I particularly like anthologies, they're a great way to try out new authors without investing too much time or money in any particular wild card author. Grey and Bennett were both new to me authors. I was able to read this as an advance review copy, but my review is entirely my honest take on the book.

Suzanne Enoch- I've read the other books in the series, so I already knew a little of the heroine's backstory, but this novella can stand alone. These two characters were likable enough I suppose, but it's one of those where they've only known each other for like one conversation, and there's interest, but suddenly near the end they both just know they're meant to be forever. It's tough to pull off, and I didn't really buy it in this case, and the character depth was a bit thin.

Amelia Grey- As with all books, this started at 3 stars in my mind. But as it went on I just enjoyed it less and less. A few chapters from the end I was leaning toward 1.5 stars but rounding up to 2, but the ending was perhaps my least favorite part of all, lol. The dialogue seemed trite, I felt like rolling my eyes at the plot, and the heroine kept making me want to say 'ugh'. It's not the worst ever, but it was a total miss for me. 1 star.

Anna Bennett- This one was enemies to lovers and fake engagement, both of which are two of my least favorite tropes, and it also had more drama than I care for, and was on the unlikely side. But... it did still make me smile quite often, and occasionally chuckle out loud. And I'm probably a bit more forgiving of unlikeliness in both holiday stories and novellas, so I'm giving this holiday novella somewhat of a pass. In the Christmas spirit I'm giving this one 3.5 stars rounded up to 4. ( )

I am voluntarily posting an honest review after reading an advance reader copy of this story.

Available on 9-28-2021, Kissing Under The Mistletoe is a anthology of short stories for the Christmas season. Three romance writers have each provided a story revolving around love for the best present ever. I enjoyed all three but I will admit that one was my favorite. A plus to these Christmas book is that the story will usually involve secondary or new characters in an existing series. It's fun to catch up on what's going on while being involved in a new romance. I thought this was a thoroughly enjoyable read.

#SusanneEnoch #AmeliaGrey #AnnaBennett #KissingUnderTheMistletoe #StMartin'sPaperbacks #historicalromance #romance #Christmas ( )

Kissing Under the Mistletoe
Holiday Anthology

Three historical holiday romance novellas to put you in the holiday spirit.

GREAT SCOT by Suzanne Enoch
Suzanne Enoch takes us to Scotland where a lady’s companion long past marriageable age finds her perfect match. This was a delight and reminded me of the series Wild Wicked Highlanders that Jane had a part in earlier. Loved her and Brennan together. (5 Stars)

CHRISTMAS AT DEWBERRY HOLLOW by Amelia Grey
Next was Amelia Grey’s story of an innkeeper’s daughter, really a lady, who meets her match when he brings his grandfather to fulfill a quest. Isabelle and Gates were perfect for one another. (3.5 Stars)

MY MISTLETOE BEAU by Anna Bennett
The final story, by Anna Bennett, has a dutiful loving daughter trying to get a treasured watch back for her father. Eva ends up in a fake relationship with Jack and over time some truths come to light for both of them. (3.5 stars)

Of the three stories, the one with Jane and Brennan was my favorite as they put a smile on my face and I could easily see them happy together forever.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Paperbacks for the ARC – This is my honest review.

4 Stars ( )