Cliquer sur une vignette pour aller sur Google Books.
Chargement... Le crime du golf (1923)par Agatha Christie
Books Read in 2018 (64) Books Read in 2024 (98) British Mystery (39) » 7 plus Books About Murder (87) Detective Stories (49) Books Read in 2023 (3,905) Books Read in 2020 (4,012) Read in 2015 (26) Chargement...
Inscrivez-vous à LibraryThing pour découvrir si vous aimerez ce livre Actuellement, il n'y a pas de discussions au sujet de ce livre. Murder on the Links (like most Christie) is smart and satisfying! You can tell this is very early Christie but it is still a very enjoyable story. Murder on the Links was as different from its predecessor as that had been from Styles. It is very French; not just in setting but in tone, Agatha admitted that she had written it in a "high-flown, fanciful" manner. She had also based the book too closely upon a real-life French murder case, which gives the story a kind of non-artistic complexity. Ultimately, this story is about the dark secrets of the French aristocracy and how individuals confuse love and money. Poirot is, as usual, a bit pompous and it is fun to see him go up against Monsieur Giraud of the Sûreté (who leads the police investigation and resents Poirot's involvement). This gives this serious mystery a little air of humor that is much needed. It is a quite enjoyable Poirot story Murder on the Links (like most Christie) is smart and satisfying! You can tell this is very early Christie but it is still a very enjoyable story. Murder on the Links was as different from its predecessor as that had been from Styles. It is very French; not just in setting but in tone, Agatha admitted that she had written it in a "high-flown, fanciful" manner. She had also based the book too closely upon a real-life French murder case, which gives the story a kind of non-artistic complexity. Ultimately, this story is about the dark secrets of the French aristocracy and how individuals confuse love and money. Poirot is, as usual, a bit pompous and it is fun to see him go up against Monsieur Giraud of the Sûreté (who leads the police investigation and resents Poirot's involvement). This gives this serious mystery a little air of humor that is much needed. It is a quite enjoyable Poirot story. I enjoyed this short novel in which Poirot, accompanied by his friend Hastings, travels to France in response to a letter from a man who appeals for his help, saying he is in danger - only to find that the letter writer has been murdered. The detective then embarks upon his own investigation against the background of the official one, which includes a Parisian detective who is dismissive of Poirot's methods and downright rude in general. I actually enjoyed this book more than the David Suchet version which I saw quite recently and which took quite a few liberties with the story. The only thing I found quite incredible is a particular athletic feat which Poirot performs towards the end of the story. But overall it was an enjoyable read and I can award it 4 stars. Perhaps because this was written and released early in Agatha Christie’s Poirot canon — 1923 — it seems more freewheeling than some later Poirot mysteries; and in many ways more charming. All the books with Hastings as narrator have an element of charm, the interactions between Hastings and Poirot giving readers an indelible impression of both men that remains steadfast and comforting all these years later. Murder on the Links in particular abounds with little nuances in their relationship, which intrudes into the mystery when Hastings falls in love, and actually goes against Poirot to protect the object of his affections. The mystery is as freewheeling and enjoyable as the interaction between Hastings and Poirot. There are daggers, a murder, then a second murder, family secrets, a trial from the past which may have bearing on the present crimes, young love, unrequited love, false confessions, confession by silence, and a pompous detective that our favorite Belgian has to outwit to uncover the true murderer; whom few readers will actually guess. At one point, a murder is prevented as Poirot himself shimmies up the side of a house! I can’t recall much physical derring-do by Poirot in other stories; the little grey cells do all the work. It’s grand. As many have noted, there is a great deal of clue-discovering and clue-explaining, but it’s handled within the charming narration of Hastings. For his part, Hasting observes Poirot mucking about with seemingly insignificant clues while the detective in charge appears to be solving the case quite nicely; all is not as it seems, however — perhaps nothing! Of all the Poirot entries, Murder on the Links feels more firmly set in the 1920s, capturing the romantic charm of a more innocent time — even when it comes to murder. There is some dark doings here, of course, but it’s all so romantic in a fashion that Murder on the Links is the epitome of a murder cozy. If the reader is willing to go along with a more relaxed and freewheeling story and style of narrative — something you don’t often get in the rigidly defined cozy — they’ll have a great time reading this one, and more often than not find themselves smiling as they root as much for Hastings to find love as they do for Poirot to figure it all out and show up the pompous detective working the case. A wonderful read for fans. aucune critique | ajouter une critique
Appartient à la sérieHercule Poirot (2) Appartient à la série éditorialeGoldmann (43953) Goldmann Krimi (9) SaPo (292) Scherz Krimi (1299) Est contenu dansAgatha Christie Crime Collection: Destination Unknown, The Murder on the Links, A Pocket Full of Rye par Agatha Christie 1920's Agatha Christie, Vol. 1: The Mysterious Affair at Styles / The Secret Adversary / Murder on the Links par Agatha Christie Hercule Poirot Bundle: The Mysterious Affair at Styles, Murder on the Links, Poirot Investigates par Agatha Christie The Perils of Poirot: The A.B.C. Murders / Murder on the Links / Peril at End House / Cat Among the Pigeons par Agatha Christie Poirot: The French Collection: Death in the Clouds / The Mystery of the Blue Train / The Murder on the Links par Agatha Christie Fait l'objet d'une adaptation dans
Une fois n'est pas coutume, nous suivons Hercule Poirot en France d'o M. Renauld - un homme qui semble avoir des moyens - a lanc un SOS imp rieux au d tective. Une limousine attendra Poirot et son ami Hastings Calais...Sur place, pas de limousine: M. Renauld a t assassin dans la nuit. On l'a trouv lard de coups de couteau, au fond d'une tombe creus e sur un terrain de golf...L'enqu te ne sera pas facile: M. Renauld tait discret sur son pass en Am rique du Sud; et les deux femmes qui, aux dires des domestiques, le rencontraient souvent le soir sont de bien myst rieuses cr atures... Poirot, comme son habitude, fera son profit du moindre indice... Aucune description trouvée dans une bibliothèque |
Discussion en coursAucunCouvertures populaires
Google Books — Chargement... GenresClassification décimale de Melvil (CDD)823.912Literature English & Old English literatures English fiction Modern Period 1901-1999 1901-1945Classification de la Bibliothèque du CongrèsÉvaluationMoyenne:
Est-ce vous ?Devenez un(e) auteur LibraryThing. |
This is an early Christie (only the third novel overall, and her second featuring Hercule Poirot), and not one of her best – clearly she was still experimenting with different types of mystery. While the killer is very hard to spot, despite/because of an abundance of (mostly contradictory) clues, unfortunately several question marks remain (
Elsewhere, the novel clearly shows its age (published in 1923): a couple of the women are rather highly strung and melodramatic, verging on the hysterical, and no one would take a diagnosis of 'brain fever' seriously these days. ( )