Cliquer sur une vignette pour aller sur Google Books.
Chargement... Most People (édition 2017)par Michael Leannah (Auteur), Jennifer E. Morris (Illustrateur)
Information sur l'oeuvreMost People par Michael Leannah
Aucun Chargement...
Inscrivez-vous à LibraryThing pour découvrir si vous aimerez ce livre Actuellement, il n'y a pas de discussions au sujet de ce livre. I like that this book emphasizes that "some people do bad things" rather than labeling certain people "bad." I was truly on board with most everything until I got to this point: "A person who is frowning and mad, or sad, or mean is like a sour grape in a bunch of sweet grapes. That person would almost always rather be happy, smiling, and laughing. Everyone looks nicer when they smile and laugh." This completely disregards the range of emotions that children feel and should feel, and instills the idea that being happy is somehow the default for "good" people, not to mention the many injustices that a great deal of children face that are completely out of their control. We need books that validate the full range of emotions that human beings experience, especially if we want children to grow up with a healthy and well-rounded approach to their mental and emotional health. The simple text of this gentle, well-meaning picture-book explores the idea that most people in the world are good - honest, kind, and willing to help those in need. The accompanying artwork depicts a diverse range of people doing good things for one another... Most People is a book with its heart very much in the right place. It was written, according to Michael Leannah's brief author note, to reassure young children, who are constantly bombarded with news stories about terrible crimes and other frightening events, that the nature of the world's people is essentially good. While I do agree with that idea, and think that a book like this could be most useful, in seeking to redress the imbalance of attention, in our news media and in ourselves, between the good and the bad in the people around us, there were some moments here where I felt that the narrative slipped up a bit. Chief amongst them, as other reviewers have noted, is the passage in which the author maintains that most people (AKA: most good people) like to smile, and that they look better doing so. There are many people of good will, people who are kindly disposed to others, that don't have effusive, bubbly personalities, and whose natural facial expression is unsmiling. This is perfectly fine, in my view, and I think there is something a little misguided about trying to cast an entire personality type as the opposite of "good," and imply (however indirectly) that there is something harmful about being either unhappy, or simply more emotionally reserved. We should be attempting to teach children about the distinction between appearance and reality, and the importance of looking beneath the surface, rather than encouraging them to think that there is something harmful in not conforming to a particular facial expression. Leaving that issue aside, I found this an enjoyable and heartwarming book. It is clearly didactic, and wears its purpose on its sleeve, but that's OK. The artwork is appealing, and depicts a nice range of people. With the proviso that parents and educators be aware of that one problematic passage, I would recommend Most People to anyone looking for children's books that encourage a positive attitude about humanity, and a trust in the goodness of those around us. aucune critique | ajouter une critique
Prix et récompensesListes notables
Looks at the goodness of most people, pointing out how many more people there are in the world who would like to help others than would like to hurt them, and even most of those who do bad things can change. Aucune description trouvée dans une bibliothèque |
Discussion en coursAucunCouvertures populaires
Google Books — Chargement... GenresClassification décimale de Melvil (CDD)170Philosophy and Psychology Ethics Ethics -- SubdivisionsClassification de la Bibliothèque du CongrèsÉvaluationMoyenne:
Est-ce vous ?Devenez un(e) auteur LibraryThing. |
What I have a hard time with is this line:
"A person who is frowning and mad, or sad, or mean is like a sour grape in a bunch of sweet grapes"
because to me that reads as a dismissal of real feelings. In fact, I think that's what troubles me about the whole book. Yes, there are a lot of angry and sad people in the world. There is a lot of hate and violence and horrible things, and we all need hope for and work towards better times. But I think a lot of those immense feelings are justified, and one of the causes of all the bad stuff in the world is that we don't talk about things that make us uncomfortable, and we don't confront things that are bad. For me, this book is a great try that fell down really hard about halfway through. Am I overthinking it? Yep. Is it worth looking at? Yep. Would I recommend it? Probably not.
If you want to check out a book that deals with some of the same themes, try Daddy, There's a Noise Outside by Kenneth Braswell. ( )