Goblet of Fire chapters 1-4 discussion!
DiscussionsHogwarts Express
Rejoignez LibraryThing pour poster.
Ce sujet est actuellement indiqué comme "en sommeil"—le dernier message date de plus de 90 jours. Vous pouvez le réveiller en postant une réponse.
1foggidawn
Hooray! We're all back from the holidays and ready for more stimulating book discussion! To new members who are joining this adventure, welcome!
This week begins our discussion of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, chapters 1-4:
1: The Riddle House 2:The Scar 3: The Invitation 4: Back to the Burrow
All right. . . talk, people!
This week begins our discussion of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, chapters 1-4:
All right. . . talk, people!
2littlegeek
Yo, peeps. I'm sick with a nasty cold, but I got off the couch to check in with y'all about Harry. What occurs to me in these chapters are this:
1. I hate the Dursley chapters.
2. Dopey people who don't read the books just aren't getting how important Sirius is. I'm sure many of them are wondering why Harry is so attached to him in OotP, because he's only got one scene in the movie of GoF.
3. Weasleys rule. I love what Fred & George do to Dudley.
See you all when the snot clears.
1. I hate the Dursley chapters.
2. Dopey people who don't read the books just aren't getting how important Sirius is. I'm sure many of them are wondering why Harry is so attached to him in OotP, because he's only got one scene in the movie of GoF.
3. Weasleys rule. I love what Fred & George do to Dudley.
See you all when the snot clears.
3foggidawn
Feel better soon, LG!
My thoughts -- it really struck me, this time through, how Voldemort always thinks he's being lied to. He says, a couple different times, I think, "Don't lie to me -- Lord Voldemort always knows." Or something along those lines. He certainly did it to Pettigrew in the first chapter. And later, in book 6, we see the young Voldemort do something similar to Dumbledore. I wonder if, since he's something of a natural at Legilimancy, he's just used to using those powers to sense deception . . . or whether he just always assumes that people are lying to him. My feeling is that he never really trusts anyone: not Pettigrew, not Bellatrix, not Sev. Or rather, he trusts them to an extent, to do his bidding, but he never entirely trusts them.
I also like that Frank describes the boy he saw on the night of the deaths at Riddle house as "a teenage boy, dark-haired and pale" -- a description which could apply to three characters which JKR consistently compares and contrasts: Harry, Voldy, and Sev.
Good point about Sirius, LG. I dislike the GoF movie so much that I try not to think about it. But you're right that Sirius does not get his due in it.
Is this the first example we've seen of "Weasleys' Wizarding Wheezes"? I love seeing the Weasley twins slowly go from prank-loving kids to businessmen, without losing any of their charm.
The "Dursley Chapters" as LG calls them are (mercifully?) brief in this book, but it's still a long time before we'll see Hogwarts!
My thoughts -- it really struck me, this time through, how Voldemort always thinks he's being lied to. He says, a couple different times, I think, "Don't lie to me -- Lord Voldemort always knows." Or something along those lines. He certainly did it to Pettigrew in the first chapter. And later, in book 6, we see the young Voldemort do something similar to Dumbledore. I wonder if, since he's something of a natural at Legilimancy, he's just used to using those powers to sense deception . . . or whether he just always assumes that people are lying to him. My feeling is that he never really trusts anyone: not Pettigrew, not Bellatrix, not Sev. Or rather, he trusts them to an extent, to do his bidding, but he never entirely trusts them.
I also like that Frank describes the boy he saw on the night of the deaths at Riddle house as "a teenage boy, dark-haired and pale" -- a description which could apply to three characters which JKR consistently compares and contrasts: Harry, Voldy, and Sev.
Good point about Sirius, LG. I dislike the GoF movie so much that I try not to think about it. But you're right that Sirius does not get his due in it.
Is this the first example we've seen of "Weasleys' Wizarding Wheezes"? I love seeing the Weasley twins slowly go from prank-loving kids to businessmen, without losing any of their charm.
The "Dursley Chapters" as LG calls them are (mercifully?) brief in this book, but it's still a long time before we'll see Hogwarts!
4Mien
I read the chapters today, but I think I have a big problem here. I hardly now ho you are talking about, and I now you will never understand what I am writing. One example:
Weasleys' Wizarding Wheezes - Bröderna Weasleys Trollkarstrick. You see the problem? If I translate the Swedish into English it looks like this: The Weasley brothers warlock magic. Any one who can guess what I mean if I write like that???
Hmmm..... I need a HP dictionary :o)
Weasleys' Wizarding Wheezes - Bröderna Weasleys Trollkarstrick. You see the problem? If I translate the Swedish into English it looks like this: The Weasley brothers warlock magic. Any one who can guess what I mean if I write like that???
Hmmm..... I need a HP dictionary :o)
5foggidawn
Mien -- I can see how that would be confusing, but stick with it! If we mention someone and you can't figure out who we're talking about, ask, and we can explain! (And I think we could have puzzled out the Weasley's thing.) Glad you've joined the discussion!
6Mien
foggidawn: I'll see what I can do. I might even learn what the names are :P (are going to buy the pocket books in English, if I can find them over here. )
One thing that hit me when I reread the first chapter today was that I don't like Pettigrew (silktail for me ;)). His so small and doesn't stand up for him self. I guess that I see the old me in him or something :o).
One thing that hit me when I reread the first chapter today was that I don't like Pettigrew (silktail for me ;)). His so small and doesn't stand up for him self. I guess that I see the old me in him or something :o).
7MellieT
When I reread the chapters it did strik me how much i actually did not like pettigrew(wormtail). I also noticed how the movie differed from the book in so many was that i was actually about to throw my movie out the window lol. But I love the ton-tounge toffee trick.
8pollysmith
Who could like pettigrew! I enjoyed(reading) hearing the maid tell her story in the pub about finding the three Riddles dead.
9gpwts
I hate hate hate hate hate The Riddle house. I always just hated that chapter. It always freaked me out, no mater how old I get.
As for my Weasly's, in this book their my age now, and I always hated this book, but I love the start of the WWW. It's nice to see the where it all started.
As for my Weasly's, in this book their my age now, and I always hated this book, but I love the start of the WWW. It's nice to see the where it all started.
10foggidawn
It is a creepy chapter, and the first time she takes us away from Harry, isn't it? I remember being struck by that the first time I read it.
11littlegeek
ah, but Harry is there, in a way.
12foggidawn
True -- unlike chapters in later books ("Spinner's End," "The Other Minister"), where he's not even viewing it on VoldyCam.
13littlegeek
VoldyCam---hahaha, good one
14foggidawn
I don't think I coined that one -- I'm betting it came from someone on the Leaky or Mugglenet -- but it makes me smile every time I get a chance to use it!
1506nwingert
The first time I read HBP, my mind did flashbacks to the first chapter of GOF; the whole Riddle background.
16gpwts
you knwo what always struck me. Is just the fact that Voldy was 17 and didn't hesitate to kill his parents with curses that should have gotten him arrested. Infact, there's speculation he made a horcrux out of their deaths. to me that's jsut....that's the end of Riddle's normal life and the beginning of Voldy's
17foggidawn
Hmmm . . . I didn't see that as part of a turning point, just the natural progression. Riddle was always nasty. We see that in Book 6. But it's an interesting way of looking at the transition from Riddle to Voldemort. Didn't Dumbledore mention that his friends were using that name for him even while he was still at school?
18gpwts
ya but there's a differnece between a nickname in school and a name the whole world fears. My friends call me Dr. Love, but it be different if the entire world knew me as that
19foggidawn
Makes sense. Usually school nicknames don't stick (otherwise the world would refer to my father as "Moose") -- but Voldemort's did. Interesting that he would stick with it, rather than thinking up something new, but I imagine that he had a sort of charisma in school that made him a little bit feared by his classmates even then.
21foggidawn
Okay, I'm gone for the weekend (well, we all know that I'll be hitting the conference Internet Cafe whenever I can, so I'll probably pop in occasionally) but here it is: your official reminder:
Read GoF chapters 5-8 for Monday!!!
Read GoF chapters 5-8 for Monday!!!
22pollysmith
Well i think Lord Voldemort stuck at his own insistance because he made it out of hiw original name.
2306nwingert
I'm re-reading Goblet of Fire and noticed a few things (apologies if they've been posted):
1. In light of what we know post-DH, Voldy used Frank's death to make his final Horcrux, but Voldy wasn't in his full form. He was in a part-ghost, part-human form, so how would he have split his soul?
2. Voldy tells Wormtail to "milk Nagini." We haven't seen what snake milk/venom does/did to Voldy, much like drinking the unicorn blood in Sorcerer's Stone.
3. Voldy and Nagini have a symbiotic connection : Nagini is inside Voldy (the milking) and Voldy is inside of Nagini (the Horcrux).
1. In light of what we know post-DH, Voldy used Frank's death to make his final Horcrux, but Voldy wasn't in his full form. He was in a part-ghost, part-human form, so how would he have split his soul?
2. Voldy tells Wormtail to "milk Nagini." We haven't seen what snake milk/venom does/did to Voldy, much like drinking the unicorn blood in Sorcerer's Stone.
3. Voldy and Nagini have a symbiotic connection : Nagini is inside Voldy (the milking) and Voldy is inside of Nagini (the Horcrux).