The Guardian's 1000 Novels Everyone Must Read

Basé sur le distinctions du livre
Guardian 1000
Membres
457 membres participants
1
54,810 membres
828 critiques
4
On Member Lists
adekker06, AngelaPerelliEbbott, koppelius, kimmig13, kaida46, DellaWanna, JackieMay197, kucher, jll1976, justifiedsinner, PaulCranswick, Nickelini, NigelDorning, lori6868, RandRPrncss, BriannaNo2, alzira89, DeboraNunes, Only2rs, booksmurf, augustau, infiniteweirdo, summonedbyfells, pewpee, thart528, pinkhouselady, VivienneR, SunflowerLibby, gjh265, cpg, Melobiotic, inskip, RachelS_89, KMcPhail, Alex_Loth, m_island, goldenmoon, lipi, jack.emerson, Crazymamie, mrmapcase, benfulton, Jennine, page520, Sisif, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, mcountr, mmonette, cindyi1218, Jonas.Pieters, TAir, Quasifesto, Jambyfool, eileenjunker, smichaelwilson, Sharlene_Kerr, Tess_W, tyrosine, millefleurs, JessGalchutt, mark, RavenHill, KJRoeth, soffitta1, kara.shamy, galaxias, paulworthington, rodriguezcommaj, Cecrow, Rtrace, otheraudra, kalait2708, Lorenzodipaola, roynetta, LouiseJones, MissJessie, pamelad, emmafclarke, darllenwr_brwd, beckibell, peterveen, tubbysdub, tuckerg, karmiel, Joao_Matheus_Andrade, tmadarasz, HilaryS1947, jefbra, miekekwant, mccin68, arne.frey, CDVicarage, Osbaldistone, rretzler, annamorphic, worcester, booksinbed, Dylan.Clites, Khiarhu, runde, Cariola, CarltonC, alberto.lupi.127, otterley, wlindboe, JacqiB, Cecily839, BomboChipolata, hscherry, SamTaylor, Simone2, Ktemene, ijderaap, puckers, lizboltuc, jaysbooks, soradsauce, kiwiflowa, FlorianKarpfinger, LARA335, Bookkat33, theradis, varielle, crabbei, dearkarla, MaddieBloom, Melquiades96, linlef, kerry1897, Tigardite, deven.bookman, m-andrews, VW_Williams, indeedox, Devlindusty, pan0ramix, NJP, eppp, chrissymorgan, Darraroche, saramh, lurlene_tx, daniel.markus.144, pickupsticks, rory1000, blackdove07, nagasravika.bodapati, deldevries, trex17, AndrewMSherman, amanda4242, Bretzky1, quondame, andreas.wpv, johnpdeever, Eowyn1, Elizabeth088, blakeje, jon_bobo, RandomOReilly, lilywren, TashMason, explorer21, jenitech, Bluewolf0411, Curran2, paruline, SonoranDreamer, Gnomenreigen, unlucky, yarb, sturlington, AikeP, Ameise1, jeffza, ahef1963, gypsysmom, leslie.98, hipdeep, alsocass, Rubenwiering, Peace2, Twixi, taxonet, Ignatius777, shemthepenman, otterlake, JuliaMaria, merrystar, ManWithAnAgenda, Luisali, roby72, souloftherose, steller0707, DeltaQueen50, ainutak, edparks, pjmvdb, hgtjoa, mspixieears, gennyt, desertbloom, NinieB
Thumbs Down
cheepychappy, alex68, aulsmith
Explications
aulsmith : This is fun, but a history of the Soviet Union might be more instructive.
Gnomenreigen: Excellent, mais pas en n°1...
Score
692.74
2
71,772 membres
1,382 critiques
½ 4.4
On Member Lists
Zeppole86, tannerjameswv, roojs, senex212, steller0707, bfolds, doraisadora, MrsPeachesLindsey, neicybee, refuge, SamMonzer, Devlindusty, Jbritz, gilroy, mangolike, johnpdeever, NJP, Andrew_Lear, RandomOReilly, Laura1124, FlorenceArt, longway, chrissymorgan, advincent, nonil, Asimina.Palaiou, dadito, Chriskap, BonnieJune54, NHNick, Darraroche, perennialreader, Gowers, nancyewhite, WilsonKoP, ironjaw, WritingSanctuary, lurlene_tx, starfishian, mlfhlibrarian, GHPeacock, Steedo, adekker06, DellaWanna, JackieMay197, jll1976, PaulCranswick, Nickelini, lori6868, alzira89, DeboraNunes, Only2rs, Molave, augustau, infiniteweirdo, summonedbyfells, thart528, trex17, VivienneR, gjh265, cpg, inskip, KMcPhail, m_island, goldenmoon, lipi, jack.emerson, Crazymamie, Jennine, page520, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, mcountr, mmonette, cindyi1218, Jambyfool, smichaelwilson, Tess_W, Rusty37, millefleurs, mark, soffitta1, kara.shamy, galaxias, paulworthington, rodriguezcommaj, Rtrace, otheraudra, kalait2708, roynetta, LouiseJones, MissJessie, pamelad, emmafclarke, AmourFou, darllenwr_brwd, beckibell, tubbysdub, karmiel, tmadarasz, HilaryS1947, anneLaure, Osbaldistone, tandah, rretzler, annamorphic, booksinbed, Dylan.Clites, Khiarhu, Cariola, wlindboe, JacqiB, BomboChipolata, hscherry, Simone2, Ktemene, jaysbooks, soradsauce, kiwiflowa, FlorianKarpfinger, LARA335, Bookkat33, dearkarla, MaddieBloom, generalkala, carringbush69, Bluewolf0411, blakeje, indeedox, Cecrow, eppp, varielle, linlef, kerry1897, rory1000, deldevries, KimarieBee, quondame, pan0ramix, SonoranDreamer, gypsysmom, ClaudiaLeticia, lilywren, jeffza, Elizabeth088, TashMason, hipdeep, Curran2, merrystar, DeltaQueen50, ahef1963, yarb, alsocass, unlucky, Dilara86, leslie.98, Peace2, RavenHill, Twixi, taxonet, charl08, kaida46, happybookie, ManWithAnAgenda, JuliaMaria, puckers, amanda4242, roby72, Luisali, paruline, brenzi, sturlington, tororojo, saramh, edparks, mspixieears, gennyt, cej1027, desertbloom, NinieB
Thumbs Down
cheepychappy, alex68, Privada, aulsmith
Explications
aulsmith : There are much better books on American racism than this one.
Score
556.98
3
74,894 membres
1,208 critiques
4.2
On Member Lists
KamieBettis, Stav, alsocass, trex17, sturlington, towermancn, Ignatius777, emmadan, Ameise1, indeedox, lavergne_rsl, anneLaure, Chrischi_HH, jwarmond, Katy11, daniel.markus.144, allgenresbookworm, jenitech, paruline, aulsmith, AngelaPerelliEbbott, kaida46, justifiedsinner, tannerjameswv, BriannaNo2, senex212, steller0707, booksmurf, pinkhouselady, SunflowerLibby, mrmapcase, Sisif, TAir, Quasifesto, Jbritz, mindymaybe, Gnomenreigen, gilroy, johnpdeever, Cecrow, Lorenzodipaola, Andrew_Lear, FlorenceArt, longway, advincent, nonil, miekekwant, CDVicarage, runde, CarltonC, lizboltuc, mlfhlibrarian, GHPeacock, theradis, Melquiades96, DellaWanna, JackieMay197, jll1976, PaulCranswick, Nickelini, DeboraNunes, Only2rs, augustau, infiniteweirdo, summonedbyfells, thart528, VivienneR, gjh265, cpg, inskip, KMcPhail, m_island, goldenmoon, lipi, jack.emerson, Jennine, page520, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, mcountr, mmonette, cindyi1218, Jambyfool, Devlindusty, smichaelwilson, Tess_W, millefleurs, mark, soffitta1, galaxias, andreas.wpv, paulworthington, otheraudra, kalait2708, NJP, LouiseJones, RandomOReilly, MissJessie, pamelad, emmafclarke, darllenwr_brwd, beckibell, karmiel, tmadarasz, HilaryS1947, loogawa, Darraroche, Osbaldistone, rretzler, annamorphic, saramh, booksinbed, Khiarhu, Cariola, wlindboe, JacqiB, BomboChipolata, hscherry, Simone2, Ktemene, jaysbooks, crabbei, pan0ramix, eppp, Eowyn1, soradsauce, kiwiflowa, FlorianKarpfinger, LARA335, Bookkat33, jon_bobo, deldevries, amanda4242, varielle, rory1000, MaddieBloom, TashMason, ayaeckel, linlef, Bluewolf0411, yarb, lilywren, quondame, Curran2, EMS_24, leslie.98, SonoranDreamer, AikeP, ahef1963, eowynfaramir, Bretzky1, merrystar, gypsysmom, Dilara86, Rusty37, smcwl, Rubenwiering, Peace2, Twixi, kerry1897, taxonet, blackdove07, happybookie, JuliaMaria, shemthepenman, Rtrace, Luisali, Crazymamie, brenzi, ManWithAnAgenda, souloftherose, BonnieJune54, roby72, Laura1124, DeltaQueen50, ainutak, pjmvdb, hgtjoa, edparks, desertbloom, mspixieears, quigui
Thumbs Down
cheepychappy, alex68, Katealayne
Explications
Gnomenreigen: 1984 d'Orwell et L'étranger de Camus, à lire en priorité.
Score
516.06
4
65,775 membres
1,089 critiques
3.9
On Member Lists
yarb, dh-writer, hatapota, janvaljan, mindymaybe, InLiverpool, mlhershey, LittleMonyet, loogawa, lee-mervin, luvthefloyd, tugrice, koppelius, Stav, roojs, bfolds, benfulton, SamMonzer, RavenHill, mangolike, Laura1124, otterlake, Ameise1, dadito, JuliaMaria, lavergne_rsl, nancyewhite, yokg27, jwarmond, kristilabrie, WritingSanctuary, Katy11, jeffza, adekker06, AngelaPerelliEbbott, tannerjameswv, lori6868, senex212, steller0707, Molave, booksmurf, Crazymamie, mrmapcase, MoIRH, gilroy, kara.shamy, johnpdeever, Rtrace, Andrew_Lear, longway, advincent, peterveen, BonnieJune54, CDVicarage, Dylan.Clites, CarltonC, jenitech, lin003, DellaWanna, JackieMay197, jll1976, PaulCranswick, Nickelini, DeboraNunes, augustau, summonedbyfells, thart528, trex17, VivienneR, gjh265, inskip, KMcPhail, m_island, goldenmoon, lipi, page520, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, mmonette, cindyi1218, Jambyfool, smichaelwilson, Tess_W, millefleurs, mark, soffitta1, galaxias, Cecrow, otheraudra, kalait2708, NJP, LouiseJones, MissJessie, tmadarasz, HilaryS1947, Darraroche, Osbaldistone, saramh, laipeng, GHPeacock, varielle, dearkarla, MaddieBloom, linlef, kerry1897, blakeje, Devlindusty, eppp, pamelad, emmafclarke, rretzler, annamorphic, booksinbed, Cariola, hgtjoa, FlorianKarpfinger, LARA335, Bookkat33, VW_Williams, deldevries, Khiarhu, JacqiB, Eowyn1, starfishian, Elizabeth088, explorer21, Simone2, blackdove07, Jennine, jaysbooks, ayaeckel, kiwiflowa, RachelS_89, quondame, FranzK72, unlucky, ManWithAnAgenda, alex68, merrystar, thecoroner, hipdeep, ahef1963, runde, Curran2, RandomOReilly, alsocass, Bretzky1, shemthepenman, Rubenwiering, Peace2, charl08, taxonet, roby72, Twixi, paruline, smcwl, puckers, happybookie, sturlington, amanda4242, DeltaQueen50, brenzi, leslie.98, gypsysmom, gennyt, edparks, mspixieears, NinieB
Thumbs Down
TashMason, cheepychappy, nebula21, Gnomenreigen, aulsmith, cej1027, mlfhlibrarian, mumfie, generalkala, Bluewolf0411, rory1000, pjmvdb, desertbloom
Explications
Gnomenreigen : Ce livre respire l'ennui.
aulsmith : I'm no longer sure how important Fitzgerald is, but even if he is, I don't think this is his best book
Score
431.16
5
53,847 membres
866 critiques
4.2
On Member Lists
Elidiane.Lima, archanads, katetheshrew, Patricia.Ralston, brenzi, loudima, lisa.m, clmcneilly, kappasigma, otterlake, JuliaMaria, smcwl, Druzba, smudgeroony, Ulrika_E, claire.rivers, kristilabrie, Eowyn1, Bretzky1, BolstenDorder, Melobiotic, Ignatius777, MoIRH, AndrewMSherman, peterveen, BonnieJune54, gypsysmom, perennialreader, charl08, mccin68, arne.frey, kaida46, ccmbdavis, roojs, hatapota, Sisif, Rusty37, eowynfaramir, FlorenceArt, nonil, yokg27, allgenresbookworm, starfishian, GHPeacock, generalkala, adekker06, AngelaPerelliEbbott, nagasravika.bodapati, lori6868, foof2you, steller0707, Only2rs, indeedox, mkunruh, kara.shamy, johnpdeever, pamelad, emmafclarke, beckibell, karmiel, CDVicarage, CarltonC, JacqiB, BomboChipolata, DellaWanna, jll1976, ManWithAnAgenda, DeboraNunes, cpg, Crazymamie, Jennine, mcountr, Tess_W, millefleurs, mark, soffitta1, galaxias, Cecrow, otheraudra, kalait2708, NJP, LouiseJones, MissJessie, HilaryS1947, nancyewhite, jaysbooks, varielle, dearkarla, jeffza, PaulCranswick, Nickelini, VivienneR, gjh265, m_island, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, cindyi1218, eppp, rretzler, saramh, wlindboe, kiwiflowa, FlorianKarpfinger, LARA335, MaddieBloom, linlef, thart528, annamorphic, booksinbed, Khiarhu, Cariola, hscherry, Simone2, Elizabeth088, VW_Williams, quondame, yarb, shemthepenman, ahef1963, alsocass, unlucky, Peace2, Dilara86, EMS_24, puckers, 0wllight, DeltaQueen50, taxonet, roby72, kerry1897, happybookie, paruline, sturlington, thecoroner, blackdove07, amanda4242, merrystar, souloftherose, Laura1124, leslie.98, J.Sealy, ainutak, gennyt, cej1027, pjmvdb, desertbloom, mspixieears, quigui, NinieB
Thumbs Down
alex68, page520, andreas.wpv, Anjali.Negi, RandomOReilly, aulsmith, Bluewolf0411
Explications
aulsmith : An early romance written by a woman. Famous, but not necessary
Score
388.2
6
45,467 membres
717 critiques
½ 3.7
On Member Lists
proserpinarex, ibinu, MoIRH, guitarkhw, evan66, Amante, rory1000, generalkala, DavidTrudgill, carringbush69, kucher, hatapota, RachelS_89, doraisadora, janvaljan, Sharlene_Kerr, andomck, InLiverpool, jenitech, starfishian, varielle, crabbei, linlef, kerry1897, deven.bookman, VW_Williams, pinkhouselady, SunflowerLibby, benfulton, DeltaQueen50, TAir, SamMonzer, Quasifesto, Jbritz, Ignatius777, mindymaybe, RavenHill, Rubenwiering, runde, hgtjoa, soradsauce, kiwiflowa, FlorianKarpfinger, LARA335, Bookkat33, dearkarla, MaddieBloom, blakeje, kaida46, tannerjameswv, jon_bobo, Brandy1411, Crazymamie, Jennine, mcountr, Devlindusty, paulworthington, RandomOReilly, Laura1124, AndrewMSherman, longway, nonil, dadito, tubbysdub, JuliaMaria, nancyewhite, wlindboe, hscherry, Simone2, adekker06, AngelaPerelliEbbott, JackieMay197, alsocass, PaulCranswick, Nickelini, augustau, thart528, trex17, VivienneR, inskip, KMcPhail, m_island, goldenmoon, lipi, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, mmonette, cindyi1218, Jambyfool, smichaelwilson, kara.shamy, advincent, peterveen, tmadarasz, ClaudiaLeticia, saramh, Khiarhu, nagasravika.bodapati, DellaWanna, jll1976, explorer21, Tess_W, millefleurs, mark, soffitta1, johnpdeever, galaxias, Cecrow, otheraudra, kalait2708, NJP, LouiseJones, beckibell, Darraroche, annamorphic, booksinbed, Cariola, Bluewolf0411, deldevries, pan0ramix, eppp, pamelad, emmafclarke, BonnieJune54, karmiel, rretzler, MissJessie, HilaryS1947, lilywren, sarahlpriest, quondame, aulsmith, AikeP, Curran2, jeffza, unlucky, ahef1963, 0wllight, shemthepenman, taxonet, Twixi, paruline, puckers, leslie.98, sturlington, souloftherose, CarltonC, roby72, gypsysmom, mspixieears, pjmvdb, desertbloom
Thumbs Down
herbertfoster, alex68, kingtimmy8282, yarb, markhopp, page520, mkunruh, FranzK72, booksaplenty1949, SaraAnn05, merrystar, thecoroner, Peace2, Eowyn1, Katealayne, WhatUsername
Explications
aulsmith: Read it as an adult.
Score
382.85
7
85,355 membres
1,133 critiques
½ 4.3
On Member Lists
Brandy1411, SonoranDreamer, floremolla, andomck, HelenGress, Elidiane.Lima, ccmbdavis, katetheshrew, Patricia.Ralston, kappasigma, cmhammond, smudgeroony, Chrischi_HH, laipeng, Schallon, Stav, foof2you, RachelS_89, doraisadora, mangolike, chrissymorgan, tubbysdub, perennialreader, arne.frey, WilsonKoP, SunflowerLibby, cpg, mrmapcase, benfulton, TAir, SamMonzer, Rusty37, Ignatius777, mindymaybe, RavenHill, Rtrace, Andrew_Lear, Dylan.Clites, jwarmond, Steedo, Curran2, kaida46, nagasravika.bodapati, tannerjameswv, Only2rs, indeedox, summonedbyfells, gjh265, explorer21, Laura1124, AndrewMSherman, otterlake, BonnieJune54, CDVicarage, Osbaldistone, BomboChipolata, kristilabrie, crabbei, adekker06, AngelaPerelliEbbott, JackieMay197, thart528, trex17, inskip, KMcPhail, lipi, Crazymamie, Jennine, mmonette, Jambyfool, FlorenceArt, nancyewhite, CarltonC, jll1976, PaulCranswick, Nickelini, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, Devlindusty, millefleurs, mark, galaxias, Cecrow, NJP, MissJessie, longway, advincent, Darraroche, Eowyn1, deldevries, pan0ramix, soffitta1, otheraudra, pamelad, emmafclarke, beckibell, gypsysmom, karmiel, rretzler, annamorphic, saramh, wlindboe, hscherry, starfishian, amanda4242, rory1000, eppp, RandomOReilly, HilaryS1947, booksinbed, LARA335, Bookkat33, varielle, generalkala, Peace2, sarahlpriest, Khiarhu, Cariola, kiwiflowa, MaddieBloom, lilywren, Simone2, linlef, merrystar, quondame, kerry1897, alsocass, ALWINN, blackdove07, AikeP, Elizabeth088, KimarieBee, jeffza, ahef1963, leslie.98, eowynfaramir, DeltaQueen50, hipdeep, 0wllight, smcwl, taxonet, paruline, Twixi, ManWithAnAgenda, sturlington, DeboraNunes, Luisali, souloftherose, puckers, quigui, J.Sealy, pjmvdb, gennyt, mspixieears, cej1027, NinieB
Thumbs Down
alex68, yarb, page520, FranzK72, booksaplenty1949, SFF1928-1973, Anjali.Negi, LouiseJones, thecoroner, aulsmith, charl08, jaysbooks
Explications
SFF1928-1973 : The very premise that everyone should read 1000 novels is faulty. What about illiterates who die in infancy?
aulsmith : Tolkien can be interesting or a slog. If you don't like it, don't read it/
Score
364.42
8
23,927 membres
444 critiques
4
On Member Lists
ianianian, telopea, yokg27, Patient, happybookie, Elizabeth088, dh-writer, conorduignan, JessGalchutt, bw94612, loogawa, Amante, alberto.lupi.127, MichaelMoreau, kucher, yarb, pewpee, Melobiotic, smcwl, anneLaure, nancyewhite, jwarmond, Eowyn1, Schallon, auntSteelbreaker, ccmbdavis, katetheshrew, otterlake, BonnieJune54, rretzler, annamorphic, booksinbed, Khiarhu, Cariola, hgtjoa, kristilabrie, Ktemene, jaysbooks, lin003, mlfhlibrarian, jeffza, kingtimmy8282, doraisadora, SamMonzer, mangolike, FlorenceArt, karmiel, Darraroche, wlindboe, JacqiB, hscherry, Simone2, soradsauce, kiwiflowa, starfishian, lori6868, SunflowerLibby, benfulton, page520, Sisif, TAir, RavenHill, Rtrace, Laura1124, AndrewMSherman, longway, advincent, HilaryS1947, ClaudiaLeticia, paruline, sturlington, goldenmoon, LouiseJones, beckibell, gypsysmom, adekker06, DellaWanna, Only2rs, indeedox, gjh265, cpg, inskip, KMcPhail, lipi, Crazymamie, Jambyfool, jll1976, PaulCranswick, VivienneR, Rusty37, pamelad, emmafclarke, Nickelini, thart528, Jennine, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, millefleurs, soffitta1, galaxias, Cecrow, NJP, linlef, Bookkat33, SonoranDreamer, LARA335, MaddieBloom, RachelS_89, amanda4242, varielle, RandomOReilly, merrystar, elkiedee, quondame, alsocass, hipdeep, Curran2, unlucky, puckers, foof2you, taxonet, kerry1897, thecoroner, roby72, Twixi, pan0ramix, ahef1963, ManWithAnAgenda, leslie.98, alex68, souloftherose, mark, DeltaQueen50, pjmvdb, ainutak, gennyt, mspixieears, cej1027, NinieB
Thumbs Down
Gnomenreigen, andreas.wpv, Anjali.Negi, aulsmith
Explications
Gnomenreigen : Drôle...au début.
aulsmith : This is fun, but I don't know why you have to read it.
sturlington: This is a children's book that adults will actually get something out of too.
Score
337.26
9
49,685 membres
721 critiques
3.9
On Member Lists
conorduignan, bw94612, familyproud, laipeng, archanads, Rubenwiering, jon_bobo, explorer21, janvaljan, kappasigma, smudgeroony, ClaudiaLeticia, claire.rivers, Chrischi_HH, mlfhlibrarian, blackdove07, doraisadora, Quasifesto, MoIRH, gilroy, mangolike, arne.frey, alberto.lupi.127, jenitech, ALWINN, Bluewolf0411, roojs, SunflowerLibby, Sisif, TAir, Ignatius777, RavenHill, Rtrace, Andrew_Lear, nonil, dadito, JuliaMaria, perennialreader, Dylan.Clites, allgenresbookworm, indeedox, summonedbyfells, goldenmoon, smichaelwilson, Osbaldistone, crabbei, kaida46, foof2you, DeboraNunes, Only2rs, trex17, VivienneR, gjh265, cpg, inskip, KMcPhail, m_island, Jennine, Jambyfool, AndrewMSherman, FlorenceArt, kerry1897, rory1000, nagasravika.bodapati, PaulCranswick, thart528, millefleurs, mark, longway, advincent, Darraroche, Peace2, CarltonC, DellaWanna, TashMason, Nickelini, Kristelh, Ell12, BentleyMay, pan0ramix, soffitta1, galaxias, Cecrow, NJP, LouiseJones, MissJessie, beckibell, karmiel, saramh, JacqiB, FlorianKarpfinger, amanda4242, linlef, deldevries, ayaeckel, eppp, pamelad, emmafclarke, rretzler, annamorphic, Simone2, lilywren, LARA335, Bookkat33, varielle, gypsysmom, booksinbed, Khiarhu, Cariola, kiwiflowa, quigui, MaddieBloom, merrystar, alsocass, elkiedee, quondame, RandomOReilly, unlucky, SonoranDreamer, yarb, Bretzky1, smcwl, sturlington, jeffza, ahef1963, paruline, 0wllight, leslie.98, taxonet, Twixi, Eowyn1, puckers, thecoroner, Crazymamie, ManWithAnAgenda, steller0707, roby72, DeltaQueen50, ainutak, edparks, cej1027, pjmvdb, desertbloom
Thumbs Down
page520, aulsmith, generalkala
Explications
aulsmith : Not anywhere as good as 1984
Score
333.32
10
64,752 membres
1,034 critiques
3.8
On Member Lists
pauljonathanrowland, Colin400, kingtimmy8282, Rubenwiering, condensate, cmhammond, jon_bobo, MrsPeachesLindsey, explorer21, andreas.wpv, evan66, familyproud, luvthefloyd, ironjaw, BriannaNo2, bfolds, brenzi, JessGalchutt, JoyceWemer, senex212, pewpee, pinkhouselady, Melobiotic, Jbritz, Lorenzodipaola, lavergne_rsl, miekekwant, carringbush69, hatapota, darllenwr_brwd, loogawa, steller0707, doraisadora, MoIRH, mangolike, Andrew_Lear, tubbysdub, JackieMay197, lori6868, Sisif, TAir, smichaelwilson, Ignatius777, RavenHill, johnpdeever, RandomOReilly, Laura1124, blakeje, AngelaPerelliEbbott, DeboraNunes, summonedbyfells, goldenmoon, AndrewMSherman, FlorenceArt, nonil, indeedox, trex17, gjh265, inskip, lipi, Crazymamie, advincent, BonnieJune54, Osbaldistone, ClaudiaLeticia, hgtjoa, happybookie, rory1000, DellaWanna, jll1976, PaulCranswick, VivienneR, Jambyfool, mark, LouiseJones, MissJessie, smcwl, CDVicarage, Nickelini, deldevries, thart528, Ell12, BentleyMay, millefleurs, soffitta1, galaxias, Cecrow, NJP, eppp, pamelad, emmafclarke, Darraroche, alsocass, nancyewhite, hscherry, VW_Williams, blackdove07, gypsysmom, MaddieBloom, linlef, CarltonC, wlindboe, Lthauskeeper, jaysbooks, starfishian, JacqiB, FlorianKarpfinger, Bookkat33, quondame, LARA335, yarb, annamorphic, Khiarhu, Cariola, amanda4242, Simone2, varielle, booksinbed, kiwiflowa, paruline, ahef1963, Curran2, KimarieBee, sturlington, pan0ramix, taxonet, 0wllight, Bretzky1, kerry1897, ManWithAnAgenda, Twixi, FranzK72, DeltaQueen50, merrystar, shemthepenman, thecoroner, roby72, alex68, puckers, ainutak, edparks, desertbloom, gennyt, pjmvdb, NinieB
Thumbs Down
MccMichaelR, page520, mkunruh, kara.shamy, Anjali.Negi, HilaryS1947, charl08, alberto.lupi.127, Katealayne, cej1027, mumfie, Bluewolf0411, aulsmith
Explications
alberto.lupi.127 : Could ever adolescent do what Cauliflower does in the book?
aulsmith : Another screwed-up adolescent forced down other adolescent's throats.
Score
308.98
11
46,646 membres
642 critiques
3.9
On Member Lists
qndeng2, MauraPol, Mirabai, tansymews, TravelerGreg, guitarkhw, Rubenwiering, ironjaw, mrmapcase, JessGalchutt, roojs, senex212, hatapota, pewpee, mkunruh, WritingSanctuary, MichaelMoreau, Melobiotic, kara.shamy, Andrew_Lear, peterveen, JuliaMaria, kristilabrie, kaida46, JackieMay197, foof2you, steller0707, page520, mcountr, otterlake, smcwl, CDVicarage, yokg27, adekker06, AngelaPerelliEbbott, nagasravika.bodapati, lori6868, SunflowerLibby, cindyi1218, MoIRH, dadito, VW_Williams, DeboraNunes, Sisif, Tess_W, Ignatius777, johnpdeever, Rtrace, longway, nonil, DellaWanna, jll1976, PaulCranswick, Only2rs, gjh265, cpg, Laura1124, FlorenceArt, beckibell, dearkarla, indeedox, VivienneR, KMcPhail, lipi, otheraudra, MissJessie, HilaryS1947, Peace2, sarahlpriest, nancyewhite, Eowyn1, happybookie, shemthepenman, Nickelini, Crazymamie, mark, LouiseJones, advincent, karmiel, mlfhlibrarian, Jennine, Jambyfool, NJP, pamelad, Darraroche, CarltonC, wlindboe, ahef1963, alsocass, thart528, Kristelh, BentleyMay, millefleurs, Ell12, soffitta1, galaxias, tandah, Elizabeth088, eppp, BonnieJune54, rretzler, Khiarhu, Cariola, jaysbooks, FlorianKarpfinger, starfishian, Dilara86, annamorphic, booksinbed, quondame, merrystar, FranzK72, kiwiflowa, linlef, yarb, thecoroner, roby72, alex68, Simone2, RachelS_89, jeffza, varielle, puckers, runde, taxonet, ManWithAnAgenda, LARA335, kerry1897, souloftherose, paruline, amanda4242, gypsysmom, sturlington, DeltaQueen50, leslie.98, NinieB, J.Sealy, ainutak, desertbloom, pjmvdb, mspixieears, gennyt
Thumbs Down
RandomOReilly, aulsmith, 0wllight, Katealayne, generalkala, Bluewolf0411
Explications
sturlington: De rigueur for these lists but a bit of a slog.
Score
291.29
12
47,194 membres
452 critiques
½ 4.5
On Member Lists
danielx, Molave, andreas.wpv, PippaKitambaa, leslie.98, sarahlpriest, Elidiane.Lima, Patricia.Ralston, gypsysmom, cmhammond, lisa.m, andomck, eowynfaramir, kappasigma, chrissymorgan, foof2you, RachelS_89, mindymaybe, paulworthington, ayaeckel, smudgeroony, katetheshrew, mcountr, Ameise1, arne.frey, KimarieBee, otterlake, miekekwant, Peace2, mlfhlibrarian, SunflowerLibby, devonport, Ignatius777, RavenHill, Rtrace, tubbysdub, BomboChipolata, Eowyn1, DeboraNunes, summonedbyfells, m_island, benfulton, explorer21, TAir, longway, adekker06, AngelaPerelliEbbott, kaida46, Only2rs, gjh265, cpg, KMcPhail, otheraudra, Laura1124, FlorenceArt, beckibell, Osbaldistone, claire.rivers, nagasravika.bodapati, alsocass, indeedox, goldenmoon, lipi, MissJessie, BonnieJune54, jll1976, PaulCranswick, inskip, Crazymamie, Kristelh, Jambyfool, pan0ramix, millefleurs, soffitta1, galaxias, RandomOReilly, AndrewMSherman, advincent, karmiel, Steedo, deldevries, Jennine, Ell12, Cecrow, NJP, emmafclarke, HilaryS1947, crabbei, EMS_24, Nickelini, thart528, quondame, hscherry, starfishian, eppp, Darraroche, nancyewhite, wlindboe, Lthauskeeper, lilywren, Bookkat33, rretzler, LARA335, merrystar, kiwiflowa, annamorphic, yarb, Khiarhu, Cariola, jeffza, AikeP, rory1000, 0wllight, MaddieBloom, blackdove07, Rusty37, varielle, ahef1963, taxonet, linlef, cej1027, MichaelMoreau, Elizabeth088, Twixi, kerry1897, paruline, dadito, ManWithAnAgenda, sturlington, Luisali, souloftherose, puckers, amanda4242, CDVicarage, DeltaQueen50, tororojo, J.Sealy, pjmvdb, mspixieears, gennyt
Thumbs Down
alex68, page520, FranzK72, booksaplenty1949, Anjali.Negi, LouiseJones, pamelad, thecoroner, aulsmith, Katealayne, jaysbooks
Explications
aulsmith : I found it a slog. Not an important read.
Score
283.64
13
48,769 membres
933 critiques
4
14
39,797 membres
500 critiques
3.9
15
40,053 membres
713 critiques
4.2
On Member Lists
essexgirl, explorer21, ClaudiaLeticia, pauljonathanrowland, Curran2, loudima, tyrosine, beanymen, floremolla, lee-mervin, lin003, TravelerGreg, familyproud, miekekwant, theradis, Steedo, Ameise1, claire.rivers, Chrischi_HH, yokg27, WilsonKoP, lurlene_tx, crabbei, Quasifesto, Gnomenreigen, andreas.wpv, Stav, SamMonzer, Lorenzodipaola, unlucky, otterlake, nonil, Dylan.Clites, hgtjoa, Bookkat33, amanda4242, merrystar, senex212, katetheshrew, hatapota, pewpee, page520, MoIRH, perennialreader, nancyewhite, starfishian, mangolike, varielle, MaddieBloom, ALWINN, foof2you, doraisadora, smichaelwilson, AndrewMSherman, FlorenceArt, hscherry, steller0707, m_island, lipi, karmiel, HilaryS1947, wlindboe, kerry1897, quigui, TAir, Rtrace, LouiseJones, linlef, adekker06, AngelaPerelliEbbott, JackieMay197, gjh265, cpg, pamelad, annamorphic, PaulCranswick, indeedox, VivienneR, Rusty37, eppp, rretzler, booksinbed, Khiarhu, cataloga, DellaWanna, Crazymamie, Kristelh, BentleyMay, soffitta1, Elizabeth088, Ell12, galaxias, Cecrow, Nickelini, blackdove07, RandomOReilly, VW_Williams, quondame, AikeP, runde, gypsysmom, alsocass, ahef1963, Twixi, paruline, Eowyn1, FranzK72, sturlington, roby72, BonnieJune54, thecoroner, alex68, DeltaQueen50, mark, leslie.98, Simone2, gennyt, cej1027, ainutak, mspixieears, desertbloom, NinieB
Thumbs Down
yarb, booksaplenty1949, bw94612, Luisali, AmourFou, aulsmith, alberto.lupi.127
Explications
booksaplenty1949 : Fascist and creepy, as Andre explains so well in My Dinner with Andre.
alberto.lupi.127 : Not so good as depicted, banal, only the "hat" is interesting...
Gnomenreigen: A lire très jeune, à relire très vieux.
Score
263.82
16
35,543 membres
623 critiques
3.9
On Member Lists
DeltaQueen50, willwin, JoyceWemer, loudima, luvthefloyd, ironjaw, TimBushell, Stav, brenzi, RachelS_89, familyproud, blackdove07, Katy11, augustau, pinkhouselady, Quasifesto, Jbritz, Gnomenreigen, ayaeckel, chrissymorgan, miekekwant, anneLaure, tannerjameswv, roojs, jon_bobo, mindymaybe, darllenwr_brwd, senex212, hatapota, pewpee, tmadarasz, kristilabrie, blakeje, tubbysdub, SunflowerLibby, smichaelwilson, MoIRH, dadito, kaida46, JackieMay197, lori6868, steller0707, johnpdeever, RandomOReilly, hipdeep, Bluewolf0411, goldenmoon, TAir, CDVicarage, Osbaldistone, crabbei, AngelaPerelliEbbott, jll1976, inskip, m_island, lipi, otheraudra, dearkarla, PaulCranswick, gjh265, AndrewMSherman, advincent, BonnieJune54, karmiel, Peace2, happybookie, DellaWanna, deldevries, VivienneR, Crazymamie, Jennine, mark, LouiseJones, HilaryS1947, Kristelh, BentleyMay, Jambyfool, Cecrow, Nickelini, thart528, Ell12, millefleurs, soffitta1, galaxias, NJP, pamelad, emmafclarke, eppp, JacqiB, gypsysmom, charl08, CarltonC, Simone2, Bookkat33, quondame, amanda4242, alsocass, unlucky, FlorianKarpfinger, Cariola, starfishian, Khiarhu, booksinbed, kiwiflowa, Rusty37, annamorphic, jeffza, varielle, runde, MaddieBloom, ahef1963, Twixi, kerry1897, foof2you, thecoroner, paruline, leslie.98, sturlington, shemthepenman, ManWithAnAgenda, puckers, roby72, edparks, desertbloom
Thumbs Down
yarb, page520, aulsmith, generalkala
Explications
aulsmith : I liked this as a kid, but now I think it's sexist and sentimental
Gnomenreigen: Le génie n'a pas besoin de 1000 pages, la preuve.
Score
254.03
17
35,553 membres
590 critiques
4
19
35,966 membres
685 critiques
4.2
On Member Lists
tyeve, FMops, gildaclone, Ben_ja_min, splendidcakes, robedia, Jdlaing, HelenGress, puckers, TravelerGreg, AmourFou, tororojo, anneLaure, lizboltuc, claire.rivers, alberto.lupi.127, jwarmond, lurlene_tx, pan0ramix, mindymaybe, mlfhlibrarian, conorduignan, mrmapcase, chrissymorgan, yokg27, quigui, Osbaldistone, Melobiotic, RavenHill, Lorenzodipaola, Andrew_Lear, charl08, pewpee, benfulton, cindyi1218, CarltonC, generalkala, foof2you, smichaelwilson, Ignatius777, nancyewhite, rory1000, DeboraNunes, steller0707, starfishian, nagasravika.bodapati, Only2rs, TAir, Darraroche, Curran2, kaida46, jll1976, KMcPhail, mark, johnpdeever, Rtrace, FlorenceArt, Bookkat33, indeedox, gjh265, inskip, lipi, Jambyfool, MissJessie, advincent, rretzler, lilywren, millefleurs, otheraudra, annamorphic, Khiarhu, JacqiB, LARA335, deldevries, Jennine, karmiel, kiwiflowa, carringbush69, DellaWanna, Crazymamie, Nickelini, thart528, Kristelh, soffitta1, NJP, LouiseJones, RandomOReilly, emmafclarke, RachelS_89, Cecrow, eppp, linlef, amanda4242, MaddieBloom, galaxias, gypsysmom, Peace2, quondame, merrystar, Elizabeth088, varielle, leslie.98, hipdeep, taxonet, ahef1963, blackdove07, paruline, DeltaQueen50, sturlington, ManWithAnAgenda, Luisali, souloftherose, BonnieJune54, CDVicarage, ainutak, cej1027, gennyt, J.Sealy
Thumbs Down
Bluewolf0411, cheepychappy, alex68, yarb, page520, FranzK72, retry, Anjali.Negi, HilaryS1947, thecoroner, aulsmith, Katealayne, jaysbooks
Explications
aulsmith : Fun but not a have to read. In fact the radio play is better.
Score
229.93
21
13,808 membres
276 critiques
3.9
On Member Lists
cataloga, DebraGraham, TashMason, dianelouise100, lucifertech15, kucher, HelenGress, splendidcakes, MichaelMoreau, bfolds, dh-writer, Mirabai, paulworthington, familyproud, Curran2, Ameise1, alberto.lupi.127, katetheshrew, janvaljan, hatapota, ClaudiaLeticia, kristilabrie, mlfhlibrarian, conorduignan, Eowyn1, blackdove07, senex212, longway, DeboraNunes, mangolike, Peace2, Lthauskeeper, nagasravika.bodapati, lori6868, summonedbyfells, kerry1897, kaida46, JackieMay197, Only2rs, pewpee, SunflowerLibby, dadito, ALWINN, pan0ramix, MissJessie, cpg, Melobiotic, m_island, quigui, TAir, indeedox, lipi, HilaryS1947, CarltonC, DellaWanna, PaulCranswick, deldevries, wlindboe, gjh265, KMcPhail, goldenmoon, pamelad, FlorenceArt, BonnieJune54, VivienneR, otheraudra, charl08, JacqiB, inskip, rretzler, jaysbooks, Jennine, LouiseJones, Bookkat33, Ell12, emmafclarke, Khiarhu, thart528, millefleurs, AikeP, booksinbed, Simone2, Crazymamie, soffitta1, Cecrow, NJP, annamorphic, MaddieBloom, Kristelh, BentleyMay, LARA335, galaxias, merrystar, quondame, gypsysmom, yarb, taxonet, smcwl, varielle, Rusty37, jeffza, FlorianKarpfinger, 0wllight, foof2you, aulsmith, DeltaQueen50, puckers, leslie.98, ayaeckel, ManWithAnAgenda, Twixi, sturlington, shemthepenman, ahef1963, Rtrace, souloftherose, roby72, mkunruh, ainutak, NinieB, mspixieears, gennyt
Thumbs Down
alex68, kingtimmy8282, page520, FranzK72, Kadi_A, Katealayne
Explications
aulsmith: You really don't have to read this, but it's fun/
Score
228.4
22
38,267 membres
1,088 critiques
4.1
23
28
34
121,021 membres
1,960 critiques
½ 4.3
On Member Lists
Curran2, fdpeters, Jdlaing, Patricia.Ralston, booksmurf, Anjali.Negi, tandah, guitarkhw, Katy11, lucifertech15, gilroy, andreas.wpv, Elidiane.Lima, dh-writer, SamMonzer, Quasifesto, Rusty37, roojs, bfolds, mrmapcase, darllenwr_brwd, tororojo, tmadarasz, paulworthington, trex17, sarahlpriest, lin003, cataloga, benfulton, SonoranDreamer, AngelaPerelliEbbott, KimarieBee, RavenHill, Mirabai, BomboChipolata, adekker06, DeboraNunes, Rtrace, merrystar, kaida46, m_island, cindyi1218, kara.shamy, jll1976, steller0707, quigui, TAir, tubbysdub, lipi, indeedox, nancyewhite, Eowyn1, ahef1963, alsocass, deldevries, Only2rs, goldenmoon, dadito, CDVicarage, thart528, MissJessie, otterlake, DellaWanna, charl08, Nickelini, VivienneR, Darraroche, Jennine, otheraudra, Crazymamie, Jambyfool, Rubenwiering, FlorenceArt, karmiel, quondame, millefleurs, Kristelh, Peace2, rretzler, amanda4242, pan0ramix, CarltonC, blackdove07, Cecrow, JacqiB, HilaryS1947, kiwiflowa, NJP, emmafclarke, booksinbed, Bookkat33, galaxias, paruline, RachelS_89, linlef, annamorphic, Simone2, varielle, Khiarhu, Twixi, FlorianKarpfinger, sturlington, leslie.98, DeltaQueen50, kerry1897, MaddieBloom, souloftherose, gypsysmom, soffitta1, BonnieJune54, puckers, ainutak, J.Sealy, edparks, cej1027, mspixieears, NinieB, gennyt
Thumbs Down
transgender, alex68, ManWithAnAgenda, yarb, page520, kjrichardson, FranzK72, Kadi_A, Luisali, pamelad, JuliaMaria, ayaeckel, thecoroner, 0wllight, mlfhlibrarian, Bluewolf0411, aulsmith, pjmvdb
Explications
0wllight : An okay book, and wonderful for children. A must read for adults? No, thank you. Longer than it needs to be and not really particularly interesting.
aulsmith : Over written. You can read about the magic education of the lost prince in Sword in the Stone in a seventh of the time.
sturlington: Not a must-read unless you are 12.
Score
183.52
41
27,988 membres
469 critiques
3.8
49