1001 Children's Books You Must Read Before You Grow Up

1
28,310 membres
513 critiques
4.1
Rang global 17
40 Members
Aquila, dara85, ejmam, smcwl, paeonia, guyalice, rainpebble, Mom2MandJ, roby72, rnnyhoff, konallis, labfs39, amanda4242, MaryKay1822, merrystar, blackdove07, telopea, deldevries, navelos, thomasandmary, paruline, EllaTim, Snubby, marycloseburn, tboonstra, rretzler, Tess_W, davisonme, cej1027, gypsysmom, ahef1963, sr994, EllenMazieKeyes, Ludmila.Smirnova, alvaret, bethanyseeley, 1Avidfan, shainaebc, steller0707, Chiken,xuesheng ,sturlington
Explications
xuesheng : While this is an important book, it is NOT included in the book "1001 Children's Books You Must Read before You Grow Up" which I think this list should be. Therefore, I vote Thumbs Down.
3
24,663 membres
525 critiques
4.1
Rang global 19
4
10,290 membres
148 critiques
3.8
Rang global 13
41 Members
Aquila, gennyt, ejmam, smcwl, paeonia, J.Sealy, aulsmith, rainpebble, Mom2MandJ, roby72, rnnyhoff, PitcherBooks, konallis, FAMeulstee, labfs39, MaryKay1822, merrystar, deldevries, thomasandmary, Snubby, marycloseburn, tboonstra, Dilara86, eclecticdodo, rretzler, Tess_W, davisonme, cej1027, mdoris, gypsysmom, al.vick, ahef1963, sr994, EllenMazieKeyes, Ludmila.Smirnova, Tinuvia, bethanyseeley, wichitafriendsschool, Rusty37, shainaebc, mozone1
Explications
PitcherBooks: JF, YA. 1880 Swiss KidLit classic. A little orphan girl's idyllic life and adventures for three years with her grandfather in the Swiss Alps disrupted by her aunt's taking her to a large town to be a companion to a rich family's daughter. A sweet story and a childhood favorite. Free ebook at Gutenberg.org.
5
1,131 membres
11 critiques
½ 3.5
Rang global 58
25 Members
Aquila, gennyt, ejmam, J.Sealy, aulsmith, roby72, PitcherBooks, FAMeulstee, labfs39, amanda4242, cbl_tn, merrystar, deldevries, paruline, EllaTim, Snubby, eassin, gypsysmom, ahef1963, mspixieears, EllenMazieKeyes, Ludmila.Smirnova, Tinuvia, nikki.nu, ManWithAnAgenda,smcwl ,konallis ,cej1027
Explications
aulsmith: This is not a children's book.
PitcherBooks: JF, YA, All Ages. 1726 BritLit Fantasy Adventure Satire Classic. CHILDREN'S VERSIONS AVAILABLE. (often covers just the Voyage to Lilliput but not always). The best PICTURE BOOK VERSION I've seen is Gulliver's Adventures in Lilliput illustrated by Gennady Spirin. The original adult edition contains 4 voyages: 1. Lilliput (tiny people); 2. Brobdingnag (Giants); 3. Laputa (Flying Island, Impractical Music & Math, Preposterous Schemes & Silly Science), Balnibarbi, Luggnagg (Aged & Infirm Immortals), Glubbdubdrib (Magician & Ghosts), and Japan; 4. Houyhnhnms (Intelligent horses rule, Human animals act as beasts of burden). Milo Winters did excellent illustrations for the YA/Adult version. Free ebook at Gutenberg.org. ... aulsmith: If that is your view, why do you have it on your list? .... Of course, if you or your particular kid doesn't like it, give it a thumbs down. "sturlington: I have read a lot of these books. I decided to use this list to track books I have read with my son. I'll thumbs down books I wouldn't read with my son or that didn't work for him." Which makes me discount most of sturlington's ratings and comments as limited and anecdotal.
merrystar: My 7-yr-old enjoyed an abridged version of this. She missed the satire and just saw adventure/fantasy
7
2,235 membres
38 critiques
3.9
Rang global 180
10 Members
Aquila, smcwl, konallis, DeltaQueen50, navelos, Snubby, marycloseburn, briarhills, gypsysmom, stefanny73,PitcherBooks
Explications
PitcherBooks : No explanation on what makes this particular edition a top 1000 must-read.