Photo de l'auteur
3 oeuvres 195 utilisateurs 11 critiques

A propos de l'auteur

Educated in the United Kingdom and the United States, Gabriel Weston studied English literature at Edinburgh University before attending medical school in London. She went on to become a member of the Royal College of Surgeons and is a part-time ear, nose, and throat surgical specialist. She lives afficher plus in London with her husband and two children. afficher moins

Comprend les noms: Gabriel Weston

Œuvres de Gabriel Weston

Dirty Work: A Novel (2013) 61 exemplaires
Wir Halbgötter (2012) 2 exemplaires

Étiqueté

Partage des connaissances

Sexe
female

Membres

Critiques

I'm wavering between 3 stars or 2. I enjoyed this story enormously until the end. And then end revealed it to be way more political - and with a distinct opinion on the opposite side of mine with no cogent or rational argument to convince me. In other words, I feel duped. Ok, I'm going with 2 because while 95% of the book was an artfully told story, the last 5% left me wanting my $$ back.
 
Signalé
susandennis | 4 autres critiques | Jun 5, 2020 |
Dirty Work by Gabriel Weston tells the story of a young surgeon who badly botches an operation. As she waits for a hospital committee to decide her fate, and as her patient lies in critical care, she thinks back over her childhood and her training. Nancy is a reclusive and hesitant person whose only personal ties are to her sister and her sister's family. Without friends in the hospital in which she works, she's less able to withstand the uncertainty that comes with having made a mistake.

Nancy is an OB GYN surgeon, and along with her other tasks, she routinely performs abortions. She and her mentor regard them as part of their natural duties, but part of her isolation at the hospital stems from the low-level harassment she undergoes from her co-workers who leave doll parts in her locker and make her life more difficult in small ways. Dirty Work addresses her reasons for performing these unpopular procedures.

While the subject matter was interesting and there is certainly a dearth of novels that address abortion, or the pressures of being fallible in life and death situations, the book was more focused on the issues raised than it was in character development or setting. Still, it packed a lot into a slender novel.
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
RidgewayGirl | 4 autres critiques | Sep 3, 2017 |
Cette critique a été écrite dans le cadre des Critiques en avant-première de LibraryThing.
NOTE: I never received this book as part of the Early Review program. I took it upon myself to borrow it from a local library 2 1/2 years after I was supposed to receive it (July 2014).

When we first meet Nancy Mullion, she is in the middle of a botched abortion. Her patient is bleeding out and she can't stop it. Subsequently, there is a four month medical tribunal; an inquisition where Nancy's actions are scrutinized to determine if she is competent to continue practicing medicine. Throughout her trial, Nancy flashes back to her childhood and the traumas she suffered as a young girl in England. The writing is fuzzy in the flashbacks. Weston purposefully keeps the abuse vague. Here's what we know about the first incident; we know Mullion was a very small child; too small to sit properly on a bar stool or hold a rubber ball in her tiny grasp. Weston emphasizes this point further to say Mullion's hand is so small it cannot encircle the bartender's penis. What? All in all, I thought Dirty Work was very disjointed in plot and character development. Weston is vague beyond being clever but one thing is clear - abortion is a stronger character than Doctor Nancy Mullion.… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
SeriousGrace | 4 autres critiques | Jan 3, 2017 |
Hard to review this book without an ideological lens. It was engrossing, well-written, and an interesting mix of the character's current life and childhood.

But when I got to the graphic descriptions of abortion I had a hard time. I have no idea if this was over the top and thus a disguised anti-abortion screed from a doctor with limited abortion experience, if any (she's an ENT doc after all).

so I just don't know, but for this reason I wouldn't recommend the book to a friend.
 
Signalé
bobbieharv | 4 autres critiques | Feb 9, 2015 |

Listes

Prix et récompenses

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi

Statistiques

Œuvres
3
Membres
195
Popularité
#112,377
Évaluation
3.2
Critiques
11
ISBN
25
Langues
4

Tableaux et graphiques