Wick Welker
Auteur de Refraction
Œuvres de Wick Welker
Needle Work 2 exemplaires
Saint Elspeth 2 exemplaires
Medora: A Post Apocalyptic Thriller 1 exemplaire
Dark Kingdom 1 exemplaire
Étiqueté
Partage des connaissances
Il n’existe pas encore de données Common Knowledge pour cet auteur. Vous pouvez aider.
Membres
Critiques
Statistiques
- Œuvres
- 9
- Membres
- 58
- Popularité
- #284,346
- Évaluation
- 4.1
- Critiques
- 7
- ISBN
- 5
Unfortunately, for me the plot didn't start to unfold in a way that I enjoyed until the very last quarter of the book. Early on, all of the character arcs turn selfish and unfriendly, which is a hard sell for me with a book. I find that books with unlikable characters have a harder time of convincing me to keep reading, and they have to give me something to care about in order to keep my interest. While the overall concept did interest me and (some of) the characters turn around later in the story, the book's length and slow pace were hard to counteract. I think if the book had been significantly shorter I would have enjoyed it more, because I would have been better able to focus on the plot instead of getting caught up in apathy for the characters.
“Is my story boring you?”
“No… I just can’t get away.”
“Away from what?”
“A terrible life.”
“It’s not just your life, my dear. It’s everyone's.”
— Wick Welker, Dark Theory
In addition, there were a few grammatical things that got in the way for me. One of them was the lack of dialogue tags. The quote above is one example, though in that quote it was still easy enough to figure out who was saying what based on context. There were other scenes where the context wasn't as obvious, and I had to count the lines to figure out who was saying what—or in scenes where there were multiple characters present, sometimes I just had to guess. Another couple of minor annoyances were places where I disagreed with the comma placement or where information was repeated overly frequently.
Beyond that, there are multiple places where the use of pronouns instead of names makes things muddled. In one example, a paragraph starts like this (with no paragraph breaks): "'Beetro,' she said without looking up. 'Keep watch around the corner. Tell me if anyone comes.' Ribcage sat on the ground, looking at the Quantizer. Carefully, she removed the silver thermos from her back and poured it into the canister on the back end of the Quantizer." To read that section, it sounds like Ribcage is the one speaking and doing all the actions. Most of it is not Ribcage, though... it's Miree. The only action Ribcage takes is that single sentence in the middle of the quote. Did this confuse me for long? No. But it and other examples like it slowed down the book and frustrated me. Generally, none of the technical issues I had with the book were major ones, and nothing was too annoying on its own, but they added up for me.
I know that I haven't been very positive so far in this review, but there were some things I enjoyed about the book as well. There are some fun scenes and good quotes. I liked some of the characters a lot, like Lucindi and Besidio; sadly they were just minor characters, and so got very little page time. As I mentioned at the start, the concept and set-up for the book fascinated me. I think there are some great ideas there. And once the book got near the plot's climax, I did enjoy the action a lot more.
But ultimately, this book was not for me. For me, it was too long, too bleak, and the characters were too unsympathetic. From initial comments in our team chat, many of the other members of my SPSFC3 team liked (or are liking) this book a lot more than I did, though, so your mileage may vary. I did really enjoy the worldbuilding behind this story, so if the issues I had with the book aren't things that are issues for you, I would definitely suggest giving this book a look. The concept is great, as long as you don't have a problem with the way it was executed here.
CW: death/murder, radiation poisoning, animal cruelty, torture, kidnapping & forced confinement, body horror, suicidal ideation, alcohol abuse & addiction
~*~ ~*~ ~*~
I read this book as part of the judging process for the 3rd Self Published Science Fiction Competition (SPSFC3), and I was provided a review copy for judging purposes. My opinions are my own and do not reflect the thoughts of my SPSFC3 team or the competition as a whole.… (plus d'informations)