Giles Smith (1) (1962–)

Giles Smith is a fan of pop music, who, like many self-respecting fans had dreams of pop stardom. This book details his obsession with pop music and his brief flirtation with the music industry as a member of the Cleaners From Venus.

The Cleaners operated at the arse-end of the music biz in the late 80's, managed by two young Scots chancers and briefly signed to RCA. In Germany. Smith recounts his trials and tribulations with the band, interspersed with anecdotes about his love of pop and the strange things it makes fans do.

Smith is a good writer, indeed it's the career he chose after the Cleaners failed to make it, and the book is broken down into bite size chapters but somehow, for me the book is less than the sum of its parts. It's amusing in places but not laugh out loud funny. The best bits are the Cleaners' story and you wish he'd gone into more detail, made the book more about that. As it is the book falls into two camps: a story about a failed pop band, and a story about one man's relationship to pop music.

So, an amusing, undemanding read. One to dip into now and again.… (plus d'informations)

Nette Anekdoten und eine Zeitreise durch die Musik der 70er, 80er und 90er (vor allem der britischen) von einem, der selbst kurze drauf und dran war ein Popstar zu werden, schließlich aber beim Musikjournalismus gelandet ist.
Rezension auf goodreads.com: Giles Smith is a fan of pop music, who, like many self-respecting fans had dreams of pop stardom. This book details his obsession with pop music and his brief flirtation with the music industry as a member of the Cleaners From Venus.

The Cleaners operated at the arse-end of the music biz in the late 80's, managed by two young Scots chancers and briefly signed to RCA. In Germany. Smith recounts his trials and tribulations with the band, interspersed with anecdotes about his love of pop and the strange things it makes fans do.

Smith is a good writer, indeed it's the career he chose after the Cleaners failed to make it, and the book is broken down into bite size chapters but somehow, for me the book is less than the sum of its parts. It's amusing in places but not laugh out loud funny. The best bits are the Cleaners' story and you wish he'd gone into more detail, made the book more about that. As it is the book falls into two camps: a story about a failed pop band, and a story about one man's relationship to pop music.… (plus d'informations)

Giles Smith's autobiography-in-music, 'Lost In Music', was so funny and wittily written I had to borrow this from the local library to read, even though soccer is not, to put it mildly, a sport I enjoy or follow to any degree. It's a funny and frivolous collection of pieces written originally for 'The Times', typically taking an incident or a quote from the then-current world of football (2005-2007) as a fuse to a firework of fantasy. The only reservation I have is his consistently vicious satire at the expense of referees in general, and Graham Poll in particular. Very funny. And a great title, which has tripped up some dozy reviewers on this and other book reviewing sites.… (plus d'informations)