Wendy Shalit
Auteur de A Return to Modesty: Discovering the Lost Virtue
A propos de l'auteur
Wendy Shalit began writing A Return to Modesty as an undergrad at Williams College, where she received her B.A. in philosophy in 1997. Shalit's essays have appeared in The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, and other publications. She currently lives with her husband and children in Toronto.
Crédit image: Helen Tansey
Œuvres de Wendy Shalit
Girls Gone Mild: Young Women Reclaim Self-Respect and Find It's Not Bad to Be Good (2007) 102 exemplaires
Étiqueté
Partage des connaissances
Membres
Critiques
A Return to Modesty: Discovering the Lost Virtue par Wendy Shalit
As a graduate project this book deserves 4 stars for in-depth research along with an engaging voice. Made for great discussions in our book group and I'd love to get my teenage, cute daughter to read it...someday.
This book is basically a rant. It’s a very pained rant, although not very true. I suppose that at that age, kids tend to either rant or screw around, but she really placed herself above them.
For some theologians, there are Seven Deadly Sins, but for much of the culture, “sin” means “lust”, end of story, and lying and bullying don’t count as sins— and pride is *good*! It’s a strategy, not the truth, and it’s hard to win over the other side when you’re so obviously lying to them.
I don’t think she understands the harm that she does to her argument. After explaining that everyone is a whore and nobody wants to shut the whores down: “What! Afraid to sound like me! I’m the greatest!”
I think the highlight for me was when she defended bars—yes, alcohol bars. Sometimes the right has this issue where they’re not sure if conservative means the Bible or conservative means ‘like folks’, not academic, so they simply assume that the two must be the same. So being clingy and possessive must be biblical because it’s the opposite of being liberated. Liberals hate something—must be great!.... Duels are great! Guys used to shoot each other down, must be romantic!
But my favorite is this: bars are “sexist”—let me pay for that beautiful— therefore they are places where women will be “treated well”, never mind all the 18th-century novels about disastrous seduction that she likes so much, and the ***whole fucking point of a book about sexual purity***! Whoops!
Enemy! Me Tarzan! Me have enemy!
And I’m going to cut it there, because I actually feel kinda bad for her.… (plus d'informations)
For some theologians, there are Seven Deadly Sins, but for much of the culture, “sin” means “lust”, end of story, and lying and bullying don’t count as sins— and pride is *good*! It’s a strategy, not the truth, and it’s hard to win over the other side when you’re so obviously lying to them.
I don’t think she understands the harm that she does to her argument. After explaining that everyone is a whore and nobody wants to shut the whores down: “What! Afraid to sound like me! I’m the greatest!”
I think the highlight for me was when she defended bars—yes, alcohol bars. Sometimes the right has this issue where they’re not sure if conservative means the Bible or conservative means ‘like folks’, not academic, so they simply assume that the two must be the same. So being clingy and possessive must be biblical because it’s the opposite of being liberated. Liberals hate something—must be great!.... Duels are great! Guys used to shoot each other down, must be romantic!
But my favorite is this: bars are “sexist”—let me pay for that beautiful— therefore they are places where women will be “treated well”, never mind all the 18th-century novels about disastrous seduction that she likes so much, and the ***whole fucking point of a book about sexual purity***! Whoops!
Enemy! Me Tarzan! Me have enemy!
And I’m going to cut it there, because I actually feel kinda bad for her.… (plus d'informations)
There were a lot of good things about this book, but I often found myself wishing she had written it about fifteen years later. She was young and a bit naive when she wrote this and some parts felt more like a rant rather than an informed and researched argument. I had a hard time following her reasoning sometimes, but I appreciate that there is a book out there defending modesty. I especially appreciated that she addressed issues of gender differences, natural consequences, and accountability.
Many of the problems we hear about today -- sexual harassment, date rape, young women who suffer from eating disorders and report feeling a lack of control over their bodies -- are all connected, I believe, to our culture's attack on modesty.
Vous aimerez peut-être aussi
Statistiques
- Œuvres
- 4
- Membres
- 685
- Popularité
- #36,934
- Évaluation
- 3.9
- Critiques
- 11
- ISBN
- 13
- Langues
- 2
- Favoris
- 2