Photo de l'auteur
4+ oeuvres 93 utilisateurs 3 critiques

A propos de l'auteur

David Parrott is a fellow and lecturer at New College, University of Oxford. His previous books include Richelieu's Army: War, Government and Society in France 1624-1642 (Cambridge, 2001). Cover Illustration: Ferdinand Hodler, The Retreat from Marignano, central fresco, c. 1900, Inventory number afficher plus LM-41994. Schweizerisches Landesmuseum, Zrich. Photo: courtesy Landesmuseum. afficher moins

Œuvres de David Parrott

Oeuvres associées

European Warfare, 1350-1750 (2010) — Contributeur — 30 exemplaires

Étiqueté

Partage des connaissances

Il n’existe pas encore de données Common Knowledge pour cet auteur. Vous pouvez aider.

Membres

Critiques

In this work David Parrott is on a mission to debunk simplistic understandings of the evolution of the European nation-state variously captured by the aphorism that "war made the state and the state made war" on one hand and taking too seriously the self-serving propaganda put out by absolutist governments that really bore little resemblance realities on the ground on the other. What that means here is that for all the claims about "mercenaries" being an inefficient and dangerous solution to a given government's military issues, Parrott finds that the hiring of military entrepreneurs and contractors often made the most sense for a government that had chosen or had been forced to go to war because only the contractors had the connections to mobilize the financial sinews that made effective military action possible, and this was a reality until the rise of real mass armies after the French Revolution.

As a point of contrast Parrott often turns to his previous work on how the French attempted to make war without native-born officers who were personally invested in their units, and who could depend upon their investment being recognized by the state. This made for haphazard success until the regime of Louis XIV embraced full-scale venality of the operational command structure in his army. This both recognized the monetary costs imposed on the nobility (whose wealth could not otherwise be accessed) while paying back the nobility in the coin that really mattered to them; recognition and social influence. The last section of this study is largely dedicated to examining social contracts such as these, as though the contractor generals of the Thirty Years War who raised armies as a speculative profit-making venture were gone, it doesn't mean that the military entrepreneur had disappeared with the Peace of Westphalia; it just means that the cut of their coat had changed.

While this should probably not be the first book one reads on the subject I found it very illuminating, particularly since as it appears that the era of the mass army as the expression of a nation-in-arms has ended and the military contractor has again become a viable instrument of state.
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
Shrike58 | Apr 25, 2019 |
An intense look at how the French government went about the business of campaigning in the 30 Years' War and managed to hang on until the end without collapsing, despite an administrative structure that could not be reformed until hostilities ceased. This being the case, Parrott does not find a case of war creating the state and the state then waging war. It seems to be much more the case that while France made war in spite of the limitations of the social structure of the military classes, it is also the case that this structure of social obligation and tradition did keep the military from collapsing. This also ties in with the limitations with the study, which I thought would be accessible on the grounds that I've studied a fair amount of Early Modern European military history. In reality, you'll be much better off if you're an advanced student of Early Modern France, if for no other reason you'll be bilingual enough to read the numerous untranslated quotes and will have a better sense of the players involved. It's still an impressive piece of scholarship.

Actually, I do have one particular gripe. Maybe it's my fault that I only speak English, but a glossary of French-specific terms would make this work much more accessible.
… (plus d'informations)
1 voter
Signalé
Shrike58 | 1 autre critique | Jun 14, 2008 |

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi

Auteurs associés

Statistiques

Œuvres
4
Aussi par
3
Membres
93
Popularité
#200,859
Évaluation
4.2
Critiques
3
ISBN
12

Tableaux et graphiques