Photo de l'auteur

Mark Paniccia

Auteur de Secret Invasion: Who Do You Trust?

7+ oeuvres 46 utilisateurs 1 Critiques

Œuvres de Mark Paniccia

Secret Invasion: Who Do You Trust? (2009) — Directeur de publication — 26 exemplaires
TokyoPop Sneaks (Summer '03) (2003) — Directeur de publication — 12 exemplaires
Amazing Fantasy [2004] #15 (2006) — Directeur de publication — 4 exemplaires
Manga Newswatch 2 1 exemplaire
Manga Newswatch 4 1 exemplaire
Hulk: Misunderstood Monster (2007) 1 exemplaire

Oeuvres associées

Marvel Monsters HC (2006) — Consulting Editor (FFF, MOTP), quelques éditions28 exemplaires
Marvel Adventures Fantastic Four Vol. 3: World's Greatest (2006) — Directeur de publication, quelques éditions13 exemplaires

Étiqueté

Partage des connaissances

Sexe
male

Membres

Critiques

I've been working my way through the major Marvel crossovers, with the latest being Secret Invasion. This book popped up as a recommendation at some point along the way and I ordered a copy.

The book starts out promising. It opens with a few stories that lead directly into events that are depicted in the main event. For example, the SWORD space station is attacked and Agent Brand ends up outside the station in a protective bubble. Here, we see her in the bubble reflecting on how she got to that point. Similar encounters for Beast and Wonder Man, and also Noh Var, follow. Then the book takes a turn.

The rest of the book is taken up by Tony Stark "reviewing" a report prepared by Maria Hill for him. In actuality, it's just an EXTENSIVE recap of events that lead into Secret Invasion. And that recap is done through large, wordy dialog boxes (of Tony "thinking to himself") coupled with images from throughout the tie-ins. Everything here is just a summary of prior material. After Tony's review, the book gives readers a Skrull "report" to his queen - which amounted to a bunch of character profiles. The book concludes with two somewhat interesting interviews with a writer and artists from the event.

Overall, this was a huge disappointment for anyone who has collected even some of the tie-in trades. I would only recommend this collection to those who don't intend to read the tie-ins at all, just the main event. Otherwise, this is a waste.
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
jshillingford | Apr 18, 2014 |

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi

Auteurs associés

Nick Lowe Editor
Jeff Parker Contributor, Illustrator
Mike Carey Contributor
Zeb Wells Contributor
Christos Gage Contributor
Brian Reed Contributor
Daniel Way Author
Greg Pak Author
Dan Slott Author
Nick Dragotta Illustrator
Kristian Donaldson Illustrator
Takeshi Miyazawa Illustrator
Pete Woods Illustrator
Khary Randolph Illustrator

Statistiques

Œuvres
7
Aussi par
2
Membres
46
Popularité
#335,831
Évaluation
½ 3.4
Critiques
1
ISBN
3