Photo de l'auteur

Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones

Auteur de Persians: The Age of the Great Kings

12+ oeuvres 292 utilisateurs 2 critiques

A propos de l'auteur

Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones is Professor of Ancient History at Cardiff University.

Œuvres de Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones

Oeuvres associées

A Companion to Greek Religion (2007) — Contributeur — 66 exemplaires
The Great Empires of the Ancient World (2009) — Contributeur — 58 exemplaires
A Companion to Ancient History (2009) — Contributeur — 34 exemplaires
Eunuchs in Antiquity and Beyond (2002) — Contributeur — 12 exemplaires
The Hellenistic World: New Perspectives (2002) — Contributeur — 9 exemplaires
Body Language in the Greek and Roman Worlds (2005) — Contributeur — 6 exemplaires
Material Culture and Social Identities in the Ancient World (2009) — Contributeur — 6 exemplaires
Herakles and Hercules : exploring a Graeco-Roman divinity (2005) — Contributeur — 4 exemplaires
Persianism in Antiquity (2017) — Contributeur — 4 exemplaires
Athena in the Classical World (2001) — Contributeur — 3 exemplaires
Ancient Greek Women in Film (2013) — Contributeur — 3 exemplaires

Étiqueté

Partage des connaissances

Membres

Critiques

Of course, any history of the Persian Empire is particularly interesting. Although it was relatively short-lived (from about 559 to 330 BCE), it dates from a period when we first have quite a few written sources. In the case of the Persian Empire, these are predominantly Greek, and therefore suspect, because for the Greeks Persia usually was the great enemy. The author of this book, Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones, puts this in the spotlight and claims to offer nothing less than a correction to that distorted Greek image. His intention is to rely mainly on other sources than Greek ones. Unfortunately, he only lives up to this to a limited extent. His account still seems to be based mainly on Greek sources, and the picture he paints of the Persian leaders (with Cyrus II and Darius the Great as epigones, of course) is just as degrading as, for example, the one Herodotus made. Only the chapters on Persian culture give a bit more space to Persian voices themselves. Moreover, towards the end the book contains a remarkable number of narrative passages, full of fictional descriptions, and without citing source (obviously, they must be Greek ones). Strange. So, this definitely makes for an interesting read, but this book doesn't deliver what it promises. More on this in my History account on Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4266316617. Thanks to Netgalley for an Advanced Reading Copy.… (plus d'informations)
½
1 voter
Signalé
bookomaniac | 1 autre critique | Feb 18, 2022 |
History is generally written by the victors; thus, attempting to come to a coherent understanding of a foe, especially one deemed "the other," can prove challenging. Such is especially true about the Achaemenid Persians.

The author has set out to write a history of the Persians which attempts to distance itself from the self-congratulating Greek narratives about who the Persians were and what they were about, instead attempting to let the Persians tell their own story based on inscriptional and archaeological evidence from the ancient Near East.

The author sets forth the story of the Persians from their arrival on the Iranian plains until Darius the Great; he then spends time talking about Persian religion, culture, court, harem, slavery, and other cultural aspects; he then tells the story from Xerxes until the end of the empire at the hands of Alexander the Great. The epilogue details modern Iran's relationship with the Achaemenid heritage.

The goal of de-centering Greek witness is commendable even if impractical: the author is still forced to grapple with the Greek sources at almost every opportunity because of the paucity of other source. Nevertheless, he does well to elevate our view and understanding of the Persians: they did create the first world empire worthy of the name, established greater stability than was seen before with the Assyrians/Babylonians or after under the Seleucids; developed a bureaucratic system which would become the model for all future world empires; and maintained their strength throughout, falling prey to a brilliant and powerful Alexander. The author notes, and it is worth the reminder, that the Persians are spoken of favorably in the Old Testament, even though there did seem to be a couple of rebellions in Judea that could have caused great distress.

While it is important to not allow the Greeks to define the way we understand the Persians, we must also remember that the Achaemenid Persians presented themselves the way they wanted to be seen. Yes, the Greek invasions were probably not as significant to the Persians as they were to the Greeks, but that does not mean they are insignificant; relative Persian silence may actually be rather deafening. Why the author feels the need to be apologetic about the slave system in Persia is historically baffling; of course there were slaves, as there were in the previous and future empires. Doesn't make it right or good, of course; but it comes with the territory.

Nevertheless, it is a recently updated history of the Persians, which is always good to have, and provides a good perspective. Recommended.

**--galley received as part of early review program
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
deusvitae | 1 autre critique | Jan 17, 2022 |

Listes

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi

Auteurs associés

James Robson Contributor
Shane Wallace Contributor, Editor
Daniel Ogden Contributor
Shaun Tougher Contributor
Douglas L. Cairns Contributor
Shelley Hales Contributor
Stephanie Winder Contributor
Rolf Strootman Contributor
Glenys Davies Contributor
David Engels Contributor
Ivana Petrovic Contributor
Craig Hardiman Contributor
Janett Morgan Contributor
Alex McAuley Contributor
Livia Capponi Contributor
Peter Schultz Contributor
Paola Ceccarelli Contributor
Stephen Colvin Contributor
Robin Lane Fox Contributor
Kostas Buraselis Contributor
Oleg Gabelko Contributor
Hans-Ulrich Wiemer Contributor
Alan B. Lloyd Contributor
Josef Wiesehöfer Contributor
Olga Palagia Contributor
Peter Franz Mittag Contributor
James I. Porter Contributor
Joseph Roisman Contributor
Sheila L. Ager Contributor
Erich Gruen Contributor
Ruth Veness Contributor
Andrew Dalby Contributor
Sue Blundell Contributor
Aideen M. Hartney Contributor
Bridget M. Thomas Contributor
Tyler Jo Smith Contributor
Eva Parisinou Contributor
Beate Wagner-Hasel Contributor
Judith Sebesta Contributor
Emma J. Stafford Contributor
Ariane Marcar Contributor
Hans von Wees Contributor
Mirielle Lee Contributor
Orit Shamir Contributor
Liz James Contributor
Silvia Milanezi Contributor
Joann Fletcher Contributor

Statistiques

Œuvres
12
Aussi par
15
Membres
292
Popularité
#80,152
Évaluation
3.8
Critiques
2
ISBN
46
Langues
3

Tableaux et graphiques