Photo de l'auteur

A propos de l'auteur

Paul N. Hehn is professor emeritus of the State University of New York at Brockport. He is a veteran of World War II (the Pacific Theater)

Œuvres de Paul N. Hehn

Étiqueté

Partage des connaissances

Sexe
male

Membres

Critiques

Paul Hehn's book "A Low Dishonest Decade", referring to a quotation from W.H. Auden, is one of the best books on the origins of World War II to appear in a long time. A necessary corrective to the overly politics and military strategy-centered analysis of popular writers like Overy, Paul Hehn gives an exceedingly expansive and thorough analysis of the economic interests of the classes and their governments in various countries and how these steered mankind into the most destructive war the world has ever seen.

Of course the main question in these books that interests the common reader is the one of blame: how could WWII and the temporary dominance of fascism have been prevented, and why did this not happen? Hehn's economic and statistical analysis gives some strong answers to these questions, without obviously making us forget that we are speaking from hindsight, and that the way to hell is paved with good intentions.

The German drive for expansionism is shown to have been inevitable, given that Hitler had decided to rearm. Since Germany had a permanent shortage of foodstuffs and raw materials as the result of its strong rearmament programme, and due to Versailles sanctions it also lacked the necessary gold and foreign currency to pay for importing it, it had to look abroad for the necessary materials. On the one hand, this was done by annexing Austria and the Czechs, which provided Germany with necessary boosts in reserves and materials during periods of crisis to allow the rearmament to continue a bit longer, and on the other hand, Germany pursued a program of using subsidized trade to make the various Eastern European states dependent on Germany, forcing them into political vassalage from which they could not escape. The failure of Polish attempts to appease the Germans and the Allies as well consequently led to the invasion of that country by Germany in 1939, with Hitler fully believing that British guarantees would once again be broken.

On the British side, the strong interests in Germany of the British upper class and British finance capital consistently kept the government from exercising a strong anti-German policy, which in turn sabotaged every French attempt at creating a strong alliance in the east to ward off German expansionism. The betrayal of the Czechs by British diplomacy was later followed by betraying Romania and Yugoslavia to the Nazis, all done in the name of protecting British trading interests in Germany as well as to prevent France, the USSR, and the US from gaining a foothold on the continent at the expense of British power. The short-sightedness and treasonous self-interest of the British upper class and of British capital is remarkable, and probably, aside from their German counterparts, the main reason all attempts to restrain Hitler's ambitions failed entirely.

Then of course there is the consideration of Germany's own industrial capital, and their interests. Hehn shows very well how the NSDAP was consistently sponsored and financed by German industrial interests, in particular the large companies of IG Farben and Krupp, which had everything to gain from a programme of increased rearmaments and subsequent war. IG Farben's needs for raw materials such as copper and chrome led it to pressure the Nazi government into further expansionism in Eastern Europe, in order to obtain the valuable stores of raw materials there, particularly in Yugoslavia. The German banks were also highly culpable, collaborating in every criminal Nazi undertaking in order to quickly obtain the benefits of plunder of foreign nations, such as taking over the strong banking establishments of Austria and Czechoslovakia. Of course Hitler's 'Lebensraum' ideals played a significant role on their own, but this was not a new concept, and in many ways the German policy of this time was (as AJP Taylor has stressed) a continuation of Wilhelmian imperialist ideals, now made even more criminal by the racist and genocidal elements contained in them.

Paul Hehn has done a masterful job showing how the fusion of various states' economic interests, in reality the interests of their ruling classes, and their political power play led to a nightmarish descent into war and genocide from which none could escape. He goes into much detail about the neocolonial interests in Eastern Europe of the various Great Powers, but also shows how these nations themselves responded to this and what their own socio-economic structures were, such as those of Romania, Czechoslovakia, and Yugoslavia. Overall, the French and the Americans seem to come off as least shameful and treasonous from Hehn's analysis (though each had plenty of cowardly and damaging actions on record), whereas the British, with their inclinations towards Germany in the hope of profit and defeating communism, come off particularly poorly.

The main downside of the book is that it is far too long, and highly repetitive after a while. In the introduction, Hehn gratefully notes the Continuum Press representative's statement of "the longer the book is, the better"; but as a reader, I doubt whether that was a good estimation. If the book had been reduced in size by at least one-third, nothing in content would have been lost, and it would have been a lot more pleasant to read. Furthermore, it must be noted that the book expects from the reader a very high prior level of knowledge of the 1930s, as well as a sizable understanding of the economics of international trade, as many names and concepts are used throughout without explanation. A small index of people in the back is some help, but not nearly enough if one hasn't read some histories of this period already (which I fortunately had). Aside from these remarks though, the book is a must-read, and an essential corrective to the overly Nazism-centered histories of WWII.
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
McCaine | Nov 21, 2007 |

Statistiques

Œuvres
2
Membres
23
Popularité
#537,598
Évaluation
5.0
Critiques
1
ISBN
3