Photo de l'auteur

Ronald William Clark

Auteur de Freud, the Man and the Cause

21 oeuvres 420 utilisateurs 3 critiques

Œuvres de Ronald William Clark

Étiqueté

Partage des connaissances

Sexe
male

Membres

Critiques

In an author’s note prefacing his novel, Ronald Clark writes of “the sliver of chance” that separates history that what might have been. The sliver of chance in this instance is the failure of the Trinity test in June 1945. With the atomic bomb an apparent dud, the United States moves forward with Operation Olympic, the invasion of the Japanese home island of Kyushu. The unintentional death of the Japanese emperor enrages the island’s population, ensuring a vigorous and bloody defense. With casualties mounting, the U.S. resorts to biological warfare and withdraws troops from Europe in preparation for an invasion of Honshu, actions which cause a split with its British ally and create an opening that the ambitious Soviets are quick to exploit.

Clark’s premise is a familiar one to readers of alternate history, having been used in novels such as David Westheimer’s [b:Death is Lighter than a Feather|278753|Death is Lighter than a Feather|David Westheimer|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1386923848s/278753.jpg|270367] and Alfred Coppel’s [b:The Burning Mountain|1486231|The Burning Mountain A Novel of the Invasion of Japan|Alfred Coppel|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1327374749s/1486231.jpg|2402666]. Yet Clark’s book is much inferior to these works. The narrative form is particularly weak; Clark attempts to relate events from the first-person perspective of a female correspondent who just happens to be at the right place at the right time to observe key developments, yet sections are also included recounting conversations more appropriate for a third-person format. Such laziness also extends to characterization; with the exception of a few historical figures, most of the characters are little more than mouthpieces for dialogue designed to move the plot along.

But perhaps the greatest weakness of the book is with the plot itself. Many of the developments in the novel seem to be less about considering the consequences of his suggested point of divergence than reaching a predetermined conclusion that is historically highly improbable. The chapters themselves are so focused on this that the action within the novel takes a back seat to explanation, with more space devoted to recounting fictional parliamentary debates than in describing the events that they are about. Fans of alternate history would be better off avoiding this book in favor of other works of the genre, most of which are superior to this tepid contribution.
… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
MacDad | Mar 27, 2020 |
A description of the strategic and tactical operations of the bomber from the days of ballooning to the present. Wright Brothers through WWII, Korea and Vietnam conflicts.
mid-70s British popular history book about the bomber. As might be expected, it focuses almost entirely on Bomber Command and the Nazis in WW2, with some decent background on the development of specialized bombers during WW1. Clark argues that the strategic bomber as a unitary war-winning force never really had an honest chance to prove itself, with both the Luftwaffe and the Allies diverted away from the "strategic" objective of leveling enemy cities to tactical missions like smashing rail-lines in France prior to Operation Overlord. Even so, low accuracy and high attrition rates meant that the pre-nuclear strategic bomber doctrine of Douhet and Mitchell might not have been workable, given the psychological resilience of civilians. Carriers in the Pacific get a mention, along with the weakness of airpower in Korea and Vietnam, but this book misses important and interesting stuff about tactical and nuclear bomber missions. Lots of photos, the best of which are borrowed from Nazi propaganda, and lots more blurry messes.… (plus d'informations)
 
Signalé
MasseyLibrary | Mar 6, 2018 |
 
Signalé
AICRAG | Apr 2, 2020 |

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi

Auteurs associés

Statistiques

Œuvres
21
Membres
420
Popularité
#58,060
Évaluation
½ 3.4
Critiques
3
ISBN
45
Langues
4

Tableaux et graphiques