(3.5 / 5)

This wasn’t my favorite book in the series, but it still has the charm that I’m used to from the series. Though Koko did, indeed, go underground, and that did play a big part in the story’s mystery, that cats weren’t terribly involved overall. That wasn’t really what led to the lower score, though, as the mystery itself wasn’t quite as interesting as it has been in other books. It didn’t help that Qwill speculated something that might have seemed wild at the time early in the book, and that turned out to be the truth. It might have been better for it to have been more of a surprise later.

Still, I actually enjoyed the fact that, though Qwill normally prefers a simple life and doesn’t have much use for money for himself, he definitely relied on it, and quickly, every time something went wrong with the cabin. I also liked the starting up of the human interest column I knew he would be writing for much of the series and the various ways Qwill is still getting used to this northern, wilder environment. Though this one didn’t stand out to me as much as others have, I enjoy the overall story and characters and look forward to continuing the series. ( )

I enjoyed this one too - I like this series. Fun and quick read. ( )

3 ½ stars, I prefer Pickax City to Mooseville for the setting, I think because I like the cast of regular characters in Pickax better then those in Mooseville. Still it was a decent mystery and the cats are always entertaining no matter the setting. ( )

I�Ûªve read many reviews of ‰ÛÏThe Cat Who‰Û_‰Û books where people complain about the character James Qwilleran, but I‰Ûªve never found him unlikeable, just human. Maybe Qwill and I have been spending too much together lately, but in this 9th outing, he got on my nerves a bit.

As the novel opens, Qwill has decided to load Koko and YumYum into their traveling picnic hamper and leave Pickaxe to spend some time at the Klingenschoen cabin by the lake in Moose County. Once there, despite the beauty of his surroundings he proceeded to piss and moan and generally be useless about all the little things that needed to be done to ‰ÛÏrough it‰Û in the luxurious cabin. Maybe all that money is going to his head. Maybe he‰Ûªs grouchy and horny because Polly was away in England for the summer. Whatever, he was just annoying. Sorry but I unapologetically prefer a man who knows how to check the damn pilot light, can hammer a nail, and isn‰Ûªt freaked out by a few spiders.

As a rule I don‰Ûªt mind the leisurely pace of these novels, but this one seemed to have even less forward momentum than usual. The mystery took quite a while to solidify, and the solution was both far-fetched and sad.

All in all, not my favorite but I‰Ûªm sure Qwill and the cats will be back in my good graces with the next installment.

Originally published: 1989

Body Count: 6 5 carpenters (bludgeoned by a serial killer who is the alter ego of a female plumber); the larcenous Captain Phlogg from the antique store (alcoholism)

Preceded by: The Cat Who Sniffed Glue

Next Up: The Cat Who Talked to Ghosts ( )

What an absolute delight to spend reading time with favorite characters Jim Qwilleran with Siamese cats Koko and Yum Yum. Jim thinks a little retreat to his log cabin in Moose County will soothe his restlessness as he's missing his friend and head librarian at Pickax, Polly Duncan. Polly has traveled to England for the summer as part of an exchange program so his favorite dinner companion and conversationalist (other than friend Arch Riker) is not available. Being at the log cabin for the summer will also allow for dinners with Riker.

Leaving Pickax in a restless state with a refrigerator on the fritz (no ice cubes!) Jim thinks the cabin will provide the soothing time he'd like to enjoy this summer. Little does he know that more than just appliances can need repair in an old log cabin. I found the repair process with Glinko's hysterical at times and at other times could commiserate with Jim's experiences calling for repair assistance. It definitely adds to the smiles of this tale.

I rarely enjoy the review blurbs on the front covers of a novel but this time the Chicago Sun-Times description is purrfect ~

"The mix of crime and cats {is] catnip to readers who like both."

I heartily agree. ( )